Written By Suki Harrar, Employment Partner at Constantine Law

The Health and Social Care 2008 (Regulated Activities) (Amendment) (Coronavirus) (No2) Regulations 2022 came into force on the 7th January 2022. They apply to the health and social care sector, both NHS and independent.

As things currently stand the Regulations dictate that those with direct face to face patient contact with service users, as part of CQC regulated activity, must be vaccinated against COVID-19 by the 1st April 2022 unless they have a valid exemption. There is a 12-week grace period so that those who have not yet had their first dose have time to do so by the 3rd February 2022 to enable them to be able to complete the course by the 31st March 2022.

Action points for employers in the Regulated Activities sector are: –

  • Determine those with face-to-face contact and advised them of the requirement to take the vaccine and the deadline.
  • Advise that those who have not had the vaccine as required a process will be followed and may lead to their dismissal by the 31st of March 2022.
  • For any exemptions and reasons for non-vaccination-consider redeployment opportunities
  • Dismissal should be a last resort but is a potential outcome since it is now a legal requirement to comply with the regulations.

Currently there are rumours that the deadlines might be moved back, given the impact this would have on number shortages in the health and social care workforce. We wait to see how this pans out, but the government appears committed to compulsory vaccination for workers in this sector as soon as feasible.

Private Sector, non-regulated CQC activities, will they follow suit?

Given the mandated vaccinations for regulated activities many private employers will also be asking if it is now reasonable for them to require employees to obtain mandatory vaccination status. There is no legal obligation to be vaccinated in the non-regulated activities sector which means that employers do not have the backing of the law to require employees to take the vaccine or to impose a “no jab, no job” approach and therefore any dismissal is unlikely to fall within the band of reasonable responses.

However, employers do have their own health and safety concerns for their workforces, and they should ensure they discharge those.  Employers that have a vaccination policy are therefore advised they should consider the following: –

  1. Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 employers are obliged to take reasonable steps to reduce any workplace risks. This duty gives employers justification for encouraging employees to be vaccinated to protect themselves and others in the workplace.
  2. Ensure no such policy is discriminatory in any way as some people may not be able to have the vaccine for medical reasons such as allergies, or, for reasons relating to religious or philosophical beliefs. It is important to address the different groups of employees who either can’t have the vaccine or may be hesitant to take the vaccine for varied reasons or be exempt. Failure to have these considerations could result in discrimination claims being brought.
  3. Set out the steps that the employer may take to discharge their health and safety duty to other employees if vaccination is either refused or not taken for whatever reason by an employee. This measure will help if an employee alleges breach of the duty of care towards them.
  4. Make clear vaccination is a personal choice in the private sector as the industry is not part of regulated activity under the CQC.
  5. Consider if you should ask the question, have you been vaccinated? Employers can ask if there is a good reason for needing to know, an example would be the safety of others. The information obtained is however health information and therefore sensitive information that must comply with data protection laws.  Where an employee refuses to answer the question then what employers can do really depends on the individual facts of the matter and the reason the question was asked in the first place.

It has not yet been tested if there is an unreasonable failure to comply with a management instruction to be vaccinated (private, non CQC regulated sector). There has however recently been a wrongful dismissal case decided by an Employment Tribunal that a care home worker who refused to be vaccinated (before the mandatory Regulations were in force) was fairy dismissed by her employer who had given her an instruction to be vaccinated.  The employee relied on her Rastafarian beliefs to take non-natural medication.  This was not however accepted.

Every employment contract contains an implied term of following reasonable instructions.  In the case of immunisations, reasonableness will no doubt look at the nature of the role, the number of vulnerable colleagues, the workplace, the contact with others and therefore the risk and exposure.  It is a risky stance to take, where the vaccine is not a legal requirement, to require you staff to take it, but you do have a duty towards all your employees to keep them safe and must balance this against the personal choice of the vaccine.