The colleague who stops speaking up in meetings may be the one most in need of support. Penny Newton-Hurley, founder of CommPassion and author of The Human Language explores how everyday communication shapes our stress levels, and how a simple framework can help teams talk more calmly.
When we picture workplace stress, we tend to imagine the visible signs: raised voices, slammed laptops, tears in the toilets. Yet some of the most significant stress I have encountered in my work as a mediator and trainer made no noise at all. It looked like a team member who had gone quiet.
More often than not, the root of that stress is not the job itself but the way people speak to each other, and to themselves, about it.
The stress chain
Our nervous system is constantly scanning for danger. At work, that danger comes from an ambiguous message, a frown across the room, or being left off an invitation. The amygdala doesn’t distinguish between a sabre-toothed tiger and a curt reply on Teams; both can set off the same rush of stress hormones.
The chain usually starts with an unclear message. “Can you pop into my office later?” with no context is enough to send many people into a spiral. Next comes the assumption: our minds fill the silence with the worst-case story. I’ve done something wrong. They’re unhappy with me. By the time the conversation happens, we arrive already defending ourselves, and the other person picks up on that tension and responds in kind.
None of this is a character flaw. It is how human brains are wired. But repeated many times a week, it leaves people in a near-constant state of alert, and that is exhausting.
What silence hides
Fight and flight get most of the attention, but freeze is just as common a response. When speaking up feels risky, many of us simply stop. We nod along, keep our heads down and save our real thoughts for the drive home.
On the surface, a quiet employee can look settled. Underneath, they may be carrying unresolved hurt, mounting anxiety and a harsh inner critic that replays every exchange. Silence gives a brief sense of control, but it rarely leads anywhere good. The issue stays unspoken, distance grows, and eventually the strain shows up as burnout, illness or someone quietly handing in their notice.
This is why wellbeing leads should treat a sudden drop in someone’s voice, in meetings, emails or one-to-ones, as information worth gently exploring, not a sign that all is well.
Safety first, wellbeing follows
Psychological safety, the shared sense that it is safe to take interpersonal risks such as asking a question, raising a concern or admitting a mistake, is often discussed as a driver of performance and innovation. I would argue it is just as much a wellbeing intervention.
When people trust that they won’t be judged or punished for being honest, they no longer have to spend energy guarding themselves. Worries are voiced while they are still manageable. Mistakes become learning rather than shame. That steady sense of safety calms the nervous system over time, which is exactly what long-term wellbeing depends on.
No wellbeing app or fruit bowl can substitute for it. Trust is built conversation by conversation.
Leaders who respond rather than react
Leaders have an outsized influence on that trust, particularly in how they handle tense moments. A reactive leader meets bad news with blame or a quick fix. A responsive leader takes a breath, gets curious and listens for what is going on beneath the words.
That listening is a wellbeing skill in its own right. When someone is anxious or upset, a solution is rarely what helps first. Empathy is. Being heard, without interruption or judgement, settles the body and makes clear thinking possible again. Only then is the conversation ready to move on to what happens next.
The MECAnism: four gears for calmer conversations
In my book, The Human Language, I set out The MECAnism, a framework rooted in Marshall Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication. Its four gears, Mind, Emotions, Core needs and Action, help us shift from automatic reaction to conscious response. I find teams get the most from it in three ways.
For inner calm. When something stings, pause and work through the gears privately. What exactly happened, as a camera would record it, without the judgement? What am I feeling? What do I need that isn’t being met: rest, respect, clarity? What would help? Often, simply naming the feeling and the need is enough to quieten the inner critic.
For listening. Use the same gears to tune into someone else. Rather than hearing criticism, listen for the feeling and the need behind it, and gently check your guess: “It sounds like you’re worried because you need this to go smoothly. Is that right?” People who feel understood rarely stay defensive for long.
For honest conversations. The gears also give structure to the things we find hardest to say, including “no”. Picture being asked to work extra hours after a heavy week. Instead of a resentful yes or a curt refusal, you might say: “I hear you’d like me to put in four more hours next week. I’m feeling anxious about that, because I’ve already done a lot of overtime and I need some rest and time with my family. I imagine you need support getting this done. Would you be willing to talk through the work so we can find the best way to cover it?”
That reply is clear about the boundary, acknowledges the other person’s needs and keeps the relationship intact. It doesn’t require anyone to be a natural communicator; just to practise a few new habits until, as with learning to drive, they become second nature.
Listening to the quiet
Wellbeing is shaped far less by policies than by the hundreds of small conversations that make up a working day. If we want people to thrive, we need to notice who has gone quiet, make it safe for them to speak, and give everyone a shared language for saying what they feel and need. The silence will start to lift.
Penny Newton-Hurley is the founder of CommPassion, a certified Psychological Safety Trainer with The Fearless Organisation, a workplace mediator and the author of The Human Language. Find out more at commpassion.co.uk.