Our regular HR Commentator, Steve Herbert considers the dangers of making assumptions and the importance of communicating effectively with your employees

Don’t assume!

Recent months have been amongst the most turbulent in British political history, so it might be reasonable to assume that the general public would now readily recognise all their national political party leaders.  Yet a quick look at recent polling indicates that only Boris Johnson is readily known to the population, despite (or perhaps because of?) his recent notoriety.

The above demonstrates just how easily assumptions can diverge from reality, and this same dynamic is often evident in the workplace too.  For employers sometimes expect their employees to fully understand and appreciate issues that are far outside of their experience or skill sets.  And a company-sponsored pension scheme often fits that description nicely.

 

Legally dictated

This is a very real problem for many employers.

For a pension offering is the only employee benefit actually dictated by UK legislation, and often the most expensive element of the remuneration package outside of salary and bonus too. It follows that savvy employers should always look to generate a return on this enforced investment through goodwill and employee engagement.

Such a return could be triggered by various tweaks to the offering.  Changes might include improved scheme design, salary sacrifice payment options, Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investment choices, reduced charges, online tools, greater functionality, or simply increased employer contributions.

All the above are good and positive steps that can be taken, yet these improvements assume that employees will fully appreciate what is being done for them.  And the simple truth is that many employees just don’t understand pension schemes.

 

Proof?

Evidence to support the above assertion can be found in a (much-delayed) report on the understanding of pension tax reliefs published by HM Revenue & Customs in April this year.

The research was originally commissioned in 2015, and was intended to be published in 2016.  However the announcement of the EU referendum at that time led to a lengthy delay, and the report outcomes have now only come to light as a result of a recent freedom of information request.

And now that the findings have finally been published, they provide real evidence of the disconnect between offering and understanding.

 

Key findings

The report’s primary function was to establish whether savers really understood and valued the very generous levels of tax relief available within UK pension schemes.  The answers were far from encouraging.

Only four in ten (41%) of those surveyed correctly believed that the government topped up pension contributions via tax relief, whilst more than a quarter (26%) thought no top up was provided, and a further third (33%) just didn’t know the answer.

More worrying still was the fact that even those pension savers who were aware of tax reliefs failed to appreciate the real value of the offering.  Basic rate taxpayers estimated that the government tax-relief “top-up” uplifted their contributions by around 6%, higher rate taxpayers by 15%.  In reality, the government “contribution” is worth 25% or 67% respectively (and even more if Salary Sacrifice payment options are utilised).

 

Where are we now?

Much has changed since 2016, most notably the extension of company-supported pension schemes to all eligible workers under Auto-Enrolment (AE) legislation, which has been (rightly) recognised as something of a national success.  Millions more workers are now saving for their retirement years, and it might therefore be assumed that the understanding and engagement issue around pension savings have also now been resolved.

Yet this is another assumption that might prove to be incorrect.

The truth is that AE has only worked so well because it relies on employee inertia rather than engagement.  As the name suggests enrolment happens automatically, often leaving a new pension saver with no better understanding of how pension savings work than those surveyed over half a decade ago.

 

Communication is key

If follows that many employers might be funding a pension scheme – often at above the minimum required levels – yet getting little or no additional return on their investment despite their good intentions and financial commitment.

This is a great shame – and an overlooked opportunity – as a good pension offering could and should act as a useful recruitment and retention tool at a time of record employment in the UK.  I would therefore strongly encourage employers to revisit their pension communications, education, and employee guidance to correct this oversight.

 

Steve Herbert is Wellbeing & Benefits Director at Partners&