Our popular HR Commentator, Steve Herbert, considers the value and scope of economic forecasts amid a harsh economic climate

The economic forecasts for 2023 make for some confusing reading.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) predicted in January that the United Kingdom will see negative growth (better known as a contraction in the economy) of around 0.6% this calendar year, worse than virtually all other advance economies.  Indeed the IMF even expect the economy of Russia (a nation both at war and suffering severe economic sanctions as a direct result of that war) to outperform that of the United Kingdom.

Yet that deeply gloomy outlook has been rather offset by some unexpected rays of sunshine from other sources.  Indeed the Bank of England (BoE) announcement on 2 February 2023 indicated that inflation – and perhaps the wider economy too – was starting to “turn the corner”.

A major think-tank – The National Institute for Economic and Social Research (NIESR) – then predicted that the UK would not enter a technical recession this year, and the latest Office for National Statistics (ONS) data indicates that the UK also narrowly avoided a recession at the end of 2022.

So, is the outlook improving?

Forecasts

Firstly, an important word about economic forecasting.

Virtually all economic forecasts – regardless of how robust the methodology and data used might be – are ultimately wrong.  Partially this is because it’s impossible to consistently predict the future accurately.  For instance, Brexit, Covid19, and Russia/Ukraine would each have seemed a remote possibility only a few years ago, let alone all three occurring in concert.

But forecasts themselves also change the outcomes actually experienced.  The prediction of (say) a recession results in consumers, businesses, trade bodies, regulators, and even governments changing their behaviours and/or taking mitigating actions.  So ultimately the output of a forecast unwittingly becomes an input to the final outcome.

Reality

It follows that economic forecasts are a useful tool, but not one that can be relied upon to accurately predict the future.  This leaves consumers and businesses doing their best to navigate their way through the challenges of the moment with no real certainty as to where it will lead the nation.  It’s often therefore a question of understanding the key economic risk factors and responding accordingly.  And in 2023 there remain two key economic challenges to face.

Firstly, inflation continues to pose a serious problem.  Whilst the Consumer Prices Index (CPI) is likely to reduce sharply this year – in particular, once the energy price spike of the start of the Russia/Ukraine war drops out of the annual figures – this will not necessarily mean a reduction in the everyday prices paid by consumers and businesses.  Rather than deflation (when prices reduce), the nation is likely to experience a prolonged period of “disinflation”, when prices continue to increase, just at a lower rate than that experienced in 2022.

The BoE currently expect this period of disinflation to last for around a year before the UK returns to somewhere nearer to the usually expected 2% rate of inflation.

But inflation is not the only challenge for hard-pressed employers and their employees.  The Bank of England has recently made its 10th consecutive increase to its “base” (also known as “bank”) rate.  The base rate now stands at 4%.

This latest increase will place further pressure on corporate and personal borrowing, and in particular on the hundreds of thousands of employees who are about to leave an existing fixed-rate mortgage.   A new fixed rate or tracker mortgage is currently likely to be priced nearer to 5.5%, a very significant monthly cost increase from the rates available just a couple of years ago (which were often less than 2%).

It should also be noted that other borrowing on non-fixed rates – and in particular credit card balances – are also exposed to interest rate rises as a result of the BoE rising bank rate.  This is a concern, not least because some consumers will be using their credit cards to pay for everyday essentials during the cost-of-living crisis.

Sunny spells?

It follows that despite some brief sunny spells, 2023 is likely to continue as a rather overcast and unsettled picture.

Employers should therefore redouble their efforts to help their employees through this stormy period.  But what support can be offered over and above pay rises and/or one-off cost of living payments?

Simple but effective tools such as debt counselling (often provided free via the employer’s chosen Employee Assistance Plan (EAP)), retail discount schemes, salary sacrifice offerings, and (of course) financial wellbeing guidance support can all help.  And even if these tools are already in place, seek to ensure that they are communicated well and regularly, and that ease of access for all is guaranteed.

As the song has it, the sun will indeed come out tomorrow.  But for now, employers need to focus on helping their employees weather the end of this harsh economic winter.

Steve Herbert is Wellbeing & Benefits Director at Partners&