In a red-hot job market, companies struggling to attract and retain top performers are often shooting themselves in the foot with outdated and discriminatory hiring practices, according to a new report from Greenhouse, a leading hiring platform.

The 2024 Candidate Experience Report, surveying nearly 3,000 employees, paints a concerning picture of UK hiring practices. While some might scoff at “wokeness,” the report underscores that Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DE&I) remain crucial for job seekers. A staggering 55% of UK applicants prioritize DE&I when deciding on positions, with the number jumping to 86% for underrepresented groups.

Discrimination and Ghosting Remain Commonplace

Alarmingly, 41% of UK candidates have faced discriminatory interview questions, often targeting protected classes like age, criminal background, and gender. The report also reveals the persistent issue of ghosting, where companies abruptly cut off communication with candidates. Over two-fifths (42%) of job seekers report being ghosted, with Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic (BAME) candidates disproportionately affected (67% more likely).

Love Bombing and Bait-and-Switch Tactics: A Recipe for Disillusionment

The report exposes two concerning trends: “love bombing” and “bait-and-switch.” Love bombing involves showering candidates with excessive praise during the interview process, only to offer a lowball salary and title that doesn’t reflect their qualifications. Over half (56%) of job seekers have encountered this tactic.

Bait-and-switch involves companies advertising a job with responsibilities that significantly differ from the actual role. Nearly a third (29%) of respondents reported this happening to them.

Transparency and Efficiency Matter to Job Seekers

Job seekers value transparency, communication, and efficiency in the hiring process. Many companies, however, are falling short. For instance, 45% of respondents haven’t heard back from half or more of the jobs they applied to, despite expecting a response within two weeks of interviewing. Additionally, 65% are frustrated by lengthy, multi-stage interviews, favoring a streamlined approach with 1-2 interview stages.

Company Culture and Brand Reputation: Power Players in Talent Acquisition

Company culture plays a significant role in attracting talent. A staggering 80% of candidates consider a company’s culture and brand when deciding to apply. Negative reviews on Glassdoor or social media can significantly hurt a company’s ability to attract top talent, with 92% of candidates stating such information would deter them from applying.

The Rise of AI: A Double-Edged Sword

While over half (51%) of candidates feel AI has impacted the job market, they’re also using it to their advantage. Nearly a third leverage AI to tailor resumes and cover letters, while over a third use it to prepare for interviews.

Modernize or Lose Out: The Urgent Call to Action

“The hiring process must be professional and respectful for all,” emphasizes Daniel Chait, CEO of Greenhouse.

“Only by modernizing their approach can companies stand out and attract top talent.” Carin Van Vuuren, Greenhouse’s CMO, echoes this sentiment, highlighting the importance of a positive employer brand and employee experience.”

The 2024 Candidate Experience Report serves as a wake-up call for HR leaders. By addressing outdated practices, fostering an inclusive culture, streamlining interviews, and prioritizing communication, companies can become attractive employers and secure the best talent in this competitive market.