Oh, We Love Them, Don’t We? 4 Dark Facts About Charismatic Staff
Going with a charismatic candidate or promoting the “popular” employee might seem natural but is it the right choice? Hogan Assessments examines the dangerous side of charisma.
Very few of us are immune to the magnetism of charisma. Charismatic workers are often seen as valuable additions to any office as they are engaging and leave a strong impression. However, there are some downsides to charisma and its impact that managers, HR staff, or simply everyone should be aware of in an office setting. Experts at Hogan Assessments – the global leader in workplace personality assessment and leadership consulting – explored four dark aspects of the dark side of charisma.
Downside #1: An Easy Path to Burn-Out
Charisma can be a way of employing impression management in both job interviews and the workplace. Impression management is a conscious or subconscious process in which people attempt to influence others’ perceptions of them. Workers more focused on presenting a strong and likeable persona spend more time on this than their responsibilities, which can severely hurt productivity and output, presenting a major disadvantage to a workforce with damaging ramifications.
Seeking social acceptance in the workplace has always had a rather blurry finish line and this has been enhanced in an environment deeply influenced by social media. Hence, without a clear indicator, charismatic employees can easily place themselves at a higher risk of over-exertion and end up weaker in their roles. This scenario often stems from feeling less confident in their skillsets or ability to complete their jobs. Therefore, they feel they need to justify their place within a team and may lean too far into relying on the likeable or charismatic traits that they may be rewarded for.
Downside #2: Operational Failure
Having charisma is not a synonym for good judgment, or the moral qualities needed to successfully meet the challenges of a role. Charismatic employees can be persuasive, but that is meaningless if they have nothing noteworthy to say. Similarly, candidates may entice recruiters and hiring managers with their charisma but may fall flat within the role as they may not be able to perform at the expected level.
Charismatic managers and leaders often have problems acknowledging they do not have all the answers, which is necessary for anyone providing leadership to a complex enterprise. Therefore, they are less willing to seek and listen to advice, which can be detrimental to any organisation, as critical feedback or insights from their team might be easily dismissed.
Downside #3: Workplace Inequalities & Team Resentment
Career success is marked by significant disparities. Not everyone begins their journey from the same starting point, nor do all paths lead to the same destination. While some ascend the corporate ladder to achieve considerable wealth, others face the harsh reality of struggling to make ends meet in roles offering barely livable wages. In this sense, personality can significantly impact career success as charismatic workers are often viewed as more “leaderlike”, despite their actual credentials which may be lacking. Additionally, prioritising charismatic team members for promotions over work ethic or performance can easily lead to resentment as many employees may feel undervalued or overlooked by these choices.
A charismatic worker with strong interpersonal skills can indeed be a great asset but must be weighed up alongside the other skills needed to perform the job to the company’s desired standard.
Downside #4: They Overpromise and Underdeliver
In an effort to gain acceptance, particularly with their superiors, charismatic individuals tend to set unrealistic goals and expectations. This is a natural tendency for people who wish to gain favor within their organization in the short-term without concern about the long-term consequences. Occasionally, things will go as planned and they will be the first to pat themselves on the back. However, it’s much more likely that expectations will not be met, and these individuals will be quick to blame those around them without accepting responsibility for their own failures.
Whether intentional or not, charismatic people can’t help but promise more than they can realistically deliver. The problem is these are politically savvy individuals who are skilled at dodging accountability time and time again. This behaviour might not be sustainable in the long run, but charismatics tend to realise that and use their charm to land another job where they can start the cycle all over again with a clean slate.