New research has revealed that having to make someone redundant, delivering negative feedback, and colleagues challenging their authority are the workplace scenarios keeping managers up at night.
The survey of over 500 UK line managers, which was commissioned by HR software provider for small and scaling businesses, Breathe HR, set out to discover how managers feel about the everyday challenges of their role.
The research found that a team member challenging their authority in front of others is the workplace scenario line managers dread the most, with over a third of respondents (35%) saying this situation would make them feel uncomfortable or worried at work.
This was closely followed by letting a team member go or making them redundant. 28% said this scenario would cause them worry or stress. With 1 in 6 employers expecting their workforce to shrink over the next year, it’s a scenario that managers need to be prepared to handle.
Overall, the workplace situations that managers are most worried or uncomfortable facing are:
- A team member challenging their authority in front of others
- Having to let somebody go or make them redundant
- Delivering negative feedback
- A team member asking for a pay rise that the business is unable to facilitate
- Handling a performance review for a colleague who’s underperforming
- Managing conflict between team members
- A team member resigning unexpectedly
- Handling complaints about themselves as a line manager
- Communicating bad news, e.g., budget cuts or layoffs
- Being asked to enforce or defend a company policy they disagree with
- Not knowing the answer to a question they are asked in front of colleagues or clients
The findings also reveal that a lack of training could be fuelling managers’ discomfort when handling the everyday challenges of their role.
Around 1 in 5 (18%) line managers received no formal training before taking on their role. 17% also said they have never been formally trained to handle tricky or unexpected workplace situations. This is despite nearly two-thirds (64%) of managers saying they would be a better line manager if they had additional training and or support.
The research also found that 3 in 5 (60%) line managers worry that mishandling a difficult work scenario will mean their team won’t think they’re good at their job. More than 2 in 5 (43%) said they regularly experience imposter syndrome.
In response to the findings, Breathe HR is calling on employers to recognise line managers‘ pivotal role in workplaces, and invest in more support, training and resources to empower these key players to navigate the everyday challenges of their role with confidence. Breathe HR has also relaunched Breathe Learn, a learning platform offering over 100+ UK-specific courses to facilitate learning for all members of the team, with targeted modules for line managers on handling challenging situations at work. Line Manager Essentials Training is also available through the Breathe Growth Academy to empower line managers with the skills to lead with confidence, authority, and impact.
Phil Coxon, Managing Director at Breathe HR said:
“Every role has its challenges. It’s up to employers to ensure that line managers are empowered with the tools, training and confidence to navigate the everyday challenges of theirs. Because when line managers succeed, so does the business.
“Line managers are the bridge between staff and leadership, and drive employee engagement, performance and retention. To build high-performance teams that thrive long-term, ensuring these key players feel confident, capable, and supported must be a strategic priority.”