a woman sitting on a couch looking at a laptop

UK employers preparing for the 2025/26 financial year end may be facing a workforce problem that does not appear in their retention reports. BI WORLDWIDE, a global leader in employee engagement and recognition, suggests that a number of employees are remaining in roles out of caution rather than commitment. This pattern, often referred to as false retention, could give organisations an incomplete picture of workplace stability as they plan for the new financial year

Financial year end is the point where organisations review productivity, wellbeing spend, engagement patterns and cultural health. This closer scrutiny is revealing a widening gap between who is staying and who is actually engaged.

Recent UK labour market analysis shows that 55% of employees are prioritising job security over ambition. More than half of younger workers believe competition for new jobs is too high to consider moving. This reflects tougher market conditions, with 2.24 jobseekers now competing for every vacancy – the highest level in more than four years – and vacancies falling below pre-pandemic levels. HR commentators confirm that ‘job hugging’ is becoming a defining 2026 trend, where retention appears strong on paper despite declining morale and productivity.

Phil Williams, Head of Employee Programmes at BI WORLDWIDE said: “Retention remains important, but at financial year end it can give an incomplete picture. Many employees are staying because the job market feels uncertain, not because they feel motivated. To understand the true state of workplace culture, organisations need to look at behavioural engagement rather than just headcount.”

Insights from BI WORLDWIDE’s behavioural datasets show that employees who receive six or more meaningful recognitions in their first six months are twice as likely to become highly engaged contributors. Employees who receive little or no early recognition show steep declines in giving recognition, receiving recognition and participating in culture, even while remaining in post. Turnover was four times lower among employees who received the highest levels of early recognition compared with those who received the least. These patterns illustrate why retention alone cannot reflect engagement health.

Further BIW insights show that recognition plays a central role in long‑term commitment. Employees confident they will be recognised are 8.4 times more likely to say they intend to stay, making recognition a stronger predictor of future retention than tenure itself. These indicators highlight that engagement and commitment often decline long before an employee decides to leave.

Workplace experts collaborating closely with BI WORLDWIDE, including organisational researcher Brad Shuck, observe that employees are working through a period of transition, where organisational pressure and unclear communication can trigger withdrawal even when individuals remain in role. Shuck notes that these early signs, often referred to as shrinking behaviours, appear as quieter participation, reduced collaboration and lower levels of peer recognition. Such behavioural indicators are not visible in retention tracking.

At the same time, UK organisations are experiencing rising wellbeing pressures and increased strain on managers, with many reporting lower levels of energy and engagement. Financial year end makes these issues more visible as businesses assess performance patterns and plan budgets. BI WORLDWIDE stresses that high retention entering FY 2026 is not a reliable indicator of a healthy culture if employees are staying because they feel unable to move elsewhere.

What organisations should do now

As leaders prepare for FY 2026, BI WORLDWIDE recommends focusing on the behavioural signals that best predict long-term contribution. These include:

  • Providing meaningful recognition early in an employee’s journey
  • Equipping managers to offer clarity, appreciation and support during periods of pressure
  • Using recognition activity, contribution patterns and peer engagement to assess cultural health

These behavioural measures provide a more accurate view of workforce stability than retention figures alone. Phil Williams added: “Employees may stay, but their energy, contribution and creativity may fall. Organisations that look beyond retention and monitor behavioural engagement will make stronger decisions about culture, performance and planning for the year ahead.”