New data analysis by Officeology, a document management specialist, reveals there have been over 11,000 paperwork-related data breaches reported to the ICO in the past five years.
Between 2020 and 2025, the ICO recorded 11,141 incidents of paperwork containing sensitive data being lost, stolen, or disposed of incorrectly in the UK. Of these, almost 1 in 5 incidents (2,103) involved employee data, including personal identifiers, health, and financial information.
In 2025 alone, there were 1,820 data breaches reported to the ICO related to paperwork mishandling. 330 of these incidents related to employee data (18%). Based on the size of organisations recording incidents, this could have affected up to 28,000 employees.
Paperwork-related incidents are considered a “non-cyber breach”, defined by the ICO as “a type of breach that does not have a clear online or technological element which involves a third party with malicious intent.”
Instances of this type of data breach have remained relatively stable over the past five years, despite digital transformation initiatives scaling up across industries and the gradual phasing out of paper-based records and communications.
How long does it take businesses to report a paperwork data breach?
UK GDPR legislation states that organisations have a duty to report personal data breaches within 72 hours of being made aware.
However, in 2025, the data analysis shows this deadline was missed in 41% of cases. In 399 incidents, it took businesses one week or more to alert the ICO and in 351 cases, it took between 72 hours to one week.
For employee data breaches, 39% of incidents (130) were reported to the ICO after the 72-hour deadline had passed.
What types of data are most affected by paperwork breaches?
The researchers at Officeology found basic personal identifiers, such as name, address and date of birth, are the most likely to be breached in a paperwork mishandling incident. In 2025, 708 incidents involved this type of data (39%), followed by health data (23%).
In incidents involving employee data, a third (112) involved the loss, theft or incorrect disposal of basic personal identifying information.
How many paperwork breaches result in a formal investigation?
The analysis also shows most paper-based breaches do not lead to a formal investigation by the ICO. Between 2020-2025, less than 5% of incidents have resulted in a formal investigation being pursued.
In 2025, just 12 instances of paperwork-related breaches were passed on to investigations teams to determine what action, if any, was suitable. This is down from 55 instances in 2024.
The ICO decided against using its formal powers in 1,429 paperwork mishandling cases last year, opting to provide guidance and advice instead.
Only one incident involving employee data being breached was formally investigated in 2025.
Adam Butler at Officeology commented on the findings and offers advice to businesses on managing offline data security:
“Our analysis of ICO data has highlighted areas of concern, specifically businesses using paper-based systems.
“While cybersecurity dominates the news, physical theft, loss or the incorrect disposal of paper records remains a significant risk to companies’ data security, including their own employees’ private information.
“GDPR legislation, the legal framework that aims to protect the privacy and personal data of individuals, is technology-neutral and applies whether data is processed online or offline. It covers any filing system intended to be used in a searchable way.
“Paper-based processes are inherently more vulnerable to human error. Adopting document management systems allows businesses to streamline workflows and store information in secure, centralised environments, helping organisations to better safeguard data and maintain compliance.”
You can view the full study here.