For many product-led ecommerce businesses, spring isn’t just a ‘busy period’. It’s the point at which the entire year is decided.
Each year, categories like home improvement, outdoor living, and seasonal goods like composite decking, from Ultra Decking see a surge in demand between March and May which accounts for a significant share of total annual sales. When it works, that surge can carry the business. When it doesn’t, the impact is hard to recover from. Most operators understand this dynamic. What’s less well recognised is how much of that risk sits not in demand itself, but in how the business is structured to respond to it.
The instinctive move is to treat demand as a capacity problem. More orders mean more work, so headcount expands accordingly. Temporary hires are brought in, part-time staff pick up additional hours, and internal teams may adopt new responsibilities to cover the gap. Match resources to volume, absorb the spike, and return to normal once it passes. So far, so logical. But in practice, the relationship between headcount and output is not so direct.
Demand during the period is rarely consistent. External factors, and particularly weather, can shift buying behaviour in ways that are difficult to predict or prepare for. A warm early spring can accelerate demand by weeks; a cold or wet spring can suppress it entirely. Week-on-week swings of 20–40% are not unusual in seasonal categories.
For smaller ecommerce businesses, which make up the majority of the sector, that volatility can expose structural weakness. Teams here are typically lean, with individuals covering multiple roles across operations, customer service, and fulfilment, and little redundancy built into the system. When demand rises sharply, these businesses don’t so much flex, as creak and grown beneath the weight.
Temporary hiring is widely understood as the solution, but that comes with its own limitations. New team members rarely reach full capacity on day one. They need time to familiarise themselves with the business and its customers. That knowledge and understanding is typically held by a small number of experienced employees. Transferring it takes time, and peak trading periods are the least forgiving environment in which to do it.
The consequence is that experienced staff become responsible not just for execution, but for enabling the temporary workforce to function. Time that would otherwise be spent fulfilling orders or resolving customer issues is redirected into onboarding, supervision, and correction. Capacity increases, but not in proportion to headcount.
Over time, this creates a pattern that repeats each year. Temporary teams are assembled, trained, and disbanded. Knowledge is built and then lost. Processes have to be re-explained. The business effectively resets its operational capability at the exact moment it needs it to be most robust.
This has commercial consequences. Delays in fulfilment, slower response times, and inconsistent customer experience all feed directly into retention and reputation. In a market where acquisition costs are already high, a poor peak-season experience can reduce the lifetime value of customers acquired at the most expensive point in the year.
Some businesses mitigate this by planning earlier and documenting processes more rigorously. Others build relationships with returning seasonal staff or invest in systems that reduce reliance on individual knowledge. These steps improve performance, but they don’t change the underlying dynamic.
A model that depends on scaling up with temporary labour during periods of maximum demand will never be truly efficient. It introduces uncertainty at the point where consistency matters most, and assumes that capacity can be added quickly without accounting for the time required to make that capacity effective.
Thus, continuity needs to be built into the system. That might mean maintaining a slightly higher baseline of staffing throughout the year, even at the cost of short-term efficiency. It might involve structuring workflows so that work can be distributed more easily across the team, rather than relying on specific individuals. In some cases, it means accepting higher fixed costs in exchange for more predictable performance.
None of these choices are straightforward, particularly for smaller operators working within tight margins. But they reflect a shift in how the seasonal problem should be understood and addressed.
If anything, seasonal demand is set to become more unpredictable as patterns of consumer behaviour continue to further fragment. The businesses that perform well despite this won’t be those that respond fastest in the moment, but those that have reduced their need to react at all. Because when your busiest period determines your entire year, the real risk isn’t missing demand, it’s relying on a system that can’t handle it when it arrives.
Allan Jeffrey, founder and CEO of Ultra Decking