The most substantive shift in UK employment law in decades – driven by the Employment Rights Act 2025 – is already exposing how unprepared many employers are for heightened legal risk, according to HR and payroll solutions provider Cintra.
From July, the reduction of the unfair dismissal qualifying period to six months means employers can no longer rely on extended probation as a risk buffer. At the same time, tougher requirements for demonstrating ‘all reasonable steps’ to prevent harassment mean tribunals are scrutinising not just intent, but evidence, process and preventative action – with compensation uplifts of up to 25% at stake.
According to Sarah Gray, Director of HR at Cintra, the reforms are already driving a sharp change in employer exposure. “This isn’t necessarily about employers getting it wrong, rather, it’s about behaviours that were tolerated for years no longer being defensible. Informal management, overlong probation periods, dusty policies. Those are the things now landing employers in trouble and what catches them out isn’t what the employee did, it’s how the employer handled it.”
Early warning signs from the frontline
Cintra reports a clear uptick in advisory demand linked directly to the legislation, with several repeat risk patterns emerging:
- A high proportion of employers operating probation periods exceeding six months, often without structured review or documented performance management.
- Regular identification of HR policies that have not been reviewed for five to ten years, despite major legislative change.
- An increase in cases where dismissal risk is driven by procedural error rather than employee behaviour.
- Growing demand for preventative compliance guidance, as employers attempt to audit gaps before issues escalate.
Gray warns that many employers still underestimate how quickly minor missteps can evolve into costly disputes. “We see time and again that businesses believe they’re compliant because they ‘did the right thing’. But tribunals judge actions and evidence, they do not judge intention. Even when there is clear justification to dismiss, failing to follow the correct process can still result in financial penalties.”
Harassment prevention shifts from policy to proof
According to Cintra, one of the most underestimated changes is the expanded requirement on employers to proactively prevent workplace harassment. Historically, many organisations relied on static policies or one-off training modules. That approach is no longer sufficient.
“A policy and a training video are not a defence anymore,” says Gray. “Employers must be able to demonstrate that they’ve assessed risk, taken proactive preventive steps, and embedded those measures into day-to-day practice. If they can’t evidence that, tribunal exposure increases immediately.”
The financial implications are significant, particularly for mid-sized businesses without in-house HR teams. Gray notes that once a complaint escalates, costs are no longer about whether the employer was ‘right’, only how expensive the failure becomes. “Once something reaches tribunal territory, it’s no longer about avoiding cost,” Gray notes. “Instead, the focus should be on controlling how much it will cost. The real opportunity is stopping issues before they escalate.”
A shift towards preventative HR
Cintra says the reforms are accelerating a broader behavioural change among employers, from reactive HR to proactive risk management. Rather than seeking advice only once issues escalate, more organisations are now requesting compliance audits, probation framework reviews and early-stage guidance.
“The employers who cope best with this shift are the ones who treat HR like any other business risk,” Gray adds. “Clean processes, up-to-date policies and early intervention reduce exposure. But ignoring the change is no longer an option.”
Cintra expects advisory demand to continue rising through the second half of 2026 as tribunals begin applying the new rules in practice – exposing legacy HR approaches that have gone unchallenged for years.