The Government’s flagship plans to overhaul zero-hours contracts could have unintended consequences for employers, seasonal workers and even the smooth running of the UK’s examination system, according to industry experts.
Ministers this week launched a consultation on reforms that would require employers to offer guaranteed hours to workers who regularly work predictable patterns. The proposals form part of Labour’s wider Employment Rights Act and are designed to tackle what the Government describes as “exploitative” zero-hours arrangements.
Under the plans, employers would be expected to offer workers contracts reflecting their average hours worked over a reference period, with the Government favouring a 12-week assessment window. Workers would also gain greater protection against last-minute shift changes and cancellations, with compensation potentially payable when shifts are altered without sufficient notice.
While the reforms have been welcomed by campaigners seeking greater job security, business groups have warned that the measures could reduce flexibility for both employers and workers.
The hospitality, retail and education sectors are among those expressing concerns that a 12-week reference period may not accurately reflect seasonal working patterns. Businesses that rely on temporary staff during busy periods such as Christmas, summer holidays or examination seasons fear they could be forced into offering guaranteed hours that do not match future demand.
Industry representatives argue that a longer reference period of up to 26 weeks would provide a fairer reflection of working patterns and reduce the risk of unintended consequences. Some have warned that employers may become more cautious about hiring temporary workers altogether if the regulatory burden becomes too great.
There are also concerns about the potential impact on sectors that depend heavily on flexible labour. Examination boards and educational organisations, which recruit large numbers of temporary invigilators and support staff during peak assessment periods, could face additional challenges if the new rules make short-term hiring more complex.
The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) has raised concerns about the plans.
Ben Willmott, Head of Public Policy, said the rules are “likely to be extremely complex and challenging to comply with, particularly for small firms or those with fluctuations in demand”.
He said: “Employers will simply find other ways to achieve workforce flexibility, relying more on self-employed contractors and fixed term contracts, for example, potentially resulting in more rather than less insecure employment.”
He also said it could hurt young people and students who use zero-hours work to fit jobs around study.
Jackie Ward, Founder at Nottingham-based TreeHuggery, pointed out that even exams could be under threat by the policy.
She said: “Exams could be plunged into chaos by this policy. Many of the exam invigilators are on zero-hour contracts – with hardly any work for 10 months of the year and then the potential to be working full-time in May and June. It is not workable.”
Kate Underwood, Founder & Chief People Strategist at Southampton-based Kate Underwood HR and Training, said over 400,000 people rely on zero-hours contracts.
She added: “I spent over a decade in hospitality, so I’ve seen zero-hours from both sides of the pass. The student wanting Fridays off for exams, and the owner staring at a half-empty diary, praying the sun comes out. Both real. Both right. That’s why the CIPD warning rings true. Pile enough complexity onto a small firm, and it won’t fight you, it’ll just sidestep you.
“Push the rota too hard and out come the contractors and fixed-term deals, the very insecurity these rules are meant to cure. Plug one leak, spring three. But let’s not pretend zero-hours has been a charity. With 401,000 people leaning on it as their main income and no promise of a single shift, ‘flexibility’ has done a lot of heavy lifting for one side.
“Here’s the bit no law can fix. You can legislate guaranteed hours, but you can’t legislate guaranteed demand. Get ‘reasonable notice’ right, and it’s real progress. Get it wrong, and you’ve just rebranded the problem. The detail here isn’t the boring bit. It’s the whole game.”
Matthew Knight, Chief Freelance Officer at Freelancing.Support, said small businesses would struggle with more red tape.
He added: “Many businesses, large and small, are already responding to increased National Insurance (NI) contributions and stronger protections for employees by moving away from permanent roles, towards contractors and freelancers. While this consultation looks to protect precarious workers, in practice there’s a risk of simply redistributing roles into self-employment – where there are already no guaranteed hours, no sick pay, no holiday entitlement, and where policy still treats it as a lifestyle choice rather than the only option for many.
“We risk employers further abdicating any responsibility towards the people they lean upon to deliver their profits, reducing investment in training, supporting early-careers talent or wellbeing at work. While increased protections are welcomed, we need to recognise the large number of people who already face limited or no protections or support systems – and design rights and protections around the person, not the type of contract.”
Business groups have additionally questioned proposals that could extend guaranteed-hours protections to workers contracted for up to 20 hours per week. Critics argue this could bring a much larger proportion of the workforce within the scope of the legislation than originally anticipated, increasing costs and administrative requirements for employers.
The Government maintains that the reforms are intended to end “one-sided flexibility” while preserving choice for workers who value flexible arrangements. Workers would still be able to remain on zero-hours contracts if they preferred, but would gain the right to be offered guaranteed hours where they regularly work predictable patterns.
According to Government estimates, the changes could benefit more than 18 million workers and help some of the lowest-paid employees avoid hundreds of pounds in lost income caused by insecure work.
However, employer organisations continue to urge ministers to proceed cautiously, warning that poorly designed regulations could reduce employment opportunities, particularly for younger workers seeking flexible or entry-level roles.
The consultation remains open until August, with businesses, workers and trade bodies invited to provide feedback before the final regulations are drafted.