Managers failing to address issues in good time is the biggest concern for employers preparing for upcoming unfair dismissal reforms, according to new research from WorkNest.
More than half of employers (54%) said their biggest concern about hiring under 6-month unfair dismissal protection is their managers on the frontline, who leaders are reliant on.
This is significantly more than concerns about tribunal claims (16%), managing poor performance during probation (16%) or dismissals linked to sickness or disability (12%).
The findings, from over 800 HR professionals and business owners, come as employers prepare for a reduction in the qualifying period for unfair dismissal claims from two years to six months from January 2027.
While there is much debate of the legal reforms, the survey of more than 890 employers and HR leaders highlights that employers are more concerned about their own internal capability to manage issues effectively.
Emma Jackson, HR Consultant at WorkNest, said: “Many employers understand that employees will qualify for unfair dismissal protection much earlier than under the current rules, but their biggest concern isn’t just the law itself, but worries around managers having the confidence and capability to deal with problems.
“Managers are needed to be the first to identify concerns around performance, conduct or attendance. If those issues aren’t addressed promptly, employers may find themselves with fewer options available once employees gain unfair dismissal protection.”
The research also suggests the reforms are already influencing employer behaviour. Almost two thirds of organisations (64%) expect the changes to make them more cautious about hiring, with 42% saying they will be slightly more cautious and 22% significantly more cautious. Just three in 10 (30%) said the reforms would have no impact on their hiring decisions.
Employers are already taking steps to prepare with more than a third (38%) said they are increasing manager training in response to the reforms, while 30% are strengthening recruitment processes. However, 16% have no changes planned and 13% still remain unsure about how they will respond.
Emma added: “The reforms place a greater emphasis on getting employment decisions right from the outset. That means having managers who are equipped in effective recruitment and selection practices, holding difficult conversations, conducting effective probation reviews and documenting concerns appropriately.
“Employers that invest in manager training and robust processes now will be far better positioned to manage risk than those that wait until the reforms come into force.”
Employers also face a shorter preparation window than many realise. Although the reforms take effect in January 2027, some employees will already have accrued the qualifying service needed to benefit from the new protections on day one, making manager readiness an immediate priority.