The death of civil servant Chloe Moffat has prompted calls for workplace mediation to become part of government disciplinary procedures, a leading employment solicitor has urged.

 

The call comes after the Treasury announced plans to reform its disciplinary procedures after Chloe took her own life, having become convinced she would lose her job following a disciplinary meeting.

 

Roy Magara, founder of Magara Law and an accredited workplace mediator, said Chloe’s case should spark a wider review of how workplace conflict is handled across the public sector, warning that employers often turn to disciplinary procedures after opportunities to resolve workplace disputes have already passed.

 

It comes as the Faculty of Public Health report warned that poorly managed disciplinary procedures have become an “urgent public health issue”. The report estimates there are around 1.7 million disciplinary cases across the UK each year, costing the economy £28.5 billion through sickness absence, resignations, dismissals and lost productivity.

 

Roy is urging government departments and employers to introduce workplace mediation before formal disciplinary investigations, arguing that not every workplace dispute needs to become a disciplinary matter.

 

He said mediation allows employers to resolve a dispute before deciding whether a formal investigation is needed.

Roy said: “The Treasury announcing plans of reform is an important step, but they’re focused on what happens once a workplace dispute has already reached a disciplinary process. Employers also need to look much earlier at how more workplace disputes can be resolved before they reach that point.”

“Employers need to think much harder about preventing more disputes from reaching that stage in the first place. Too often, the first real conversation happens once a disciplinary process has already begun.

“In my experience, workplace disputes rarely begin with the issue that eventually appears in a disciplinary investigation. More often, they’ve been building for some time because concerns haven’t been addressed or people have stopped talking to each other.

“Once a formal disciplinary investigation begins, employers are dealing with a dispute that’s already escalated. Mediation gives employers the chance to step in while there’s still an opportunity to resolve the issue. It gives people the chance to understand what’s happened and whether the working relationship can still be repaired.

“Formal disciplinary procedures will always be necessary in cases involving serious misconduct. But there are many workplace disputes where an earlier intervention could prevent months of investigation, absence, stress and management time later on.”

The Faculty of Public Health has called for formal disciplinary investigations to become a last resort wherever possible. Its report highlighted Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board, which reduced formal investigations by 71% after introducing an early-resolution approach, preventing more than 3,000 sickness absence days and saving at least £700,000.

 

Roy said those findings showed employers should place greater emphasis on resolving conflict before it escalates.

 

“I hope one of the lasting outcomes from Chloe’s case is that employers feel more confident stepping into workplace conflict much earlier,” he added.

 

“If more organisations became confident dealing with conflict earlier, I think we’d see fewer disputes reaching formal investigations in the first place.”

 

“The Treasury has quite rightly looked at what happens during a disciplinary process. Employers now have an opportunity to look much more closely at everything that happens before one.”