The Part-time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000 protect part-time employees and workers from being treated less favourably than a comparable full-time worker.

However, many part-time employees still face less favourable treatment than full-time workers, solely because of their employment status. Now, the ruling in Augustine v Data Cars Ltd strengthens protection for part-time workers.

Alex Hodson, Senior Associate at Redmans Solicitors, explains how this ruling impacts part-time workers and key takeaways for employers.

Part-Time Workers’ Protection: The Starting Point

A part time employee pursuing a claim must show less favourable treatment, “on the ground that” they were part-time, and that it was not justified on objective grounds.

The protection can apply to pay, leave, pensions and benefits, access to training and promotion, career breaks and transfers, and redundancy arrangements. A worker may also ask for a written statement of the reasons for alleged less favourable treatment.

As such, pro-rating pay, holidays and many other benefits may often be appropriate. However, equal wording does not automatically produce equal treatment in practice.

What Happened in Augustine V Data Cars Ltd?

Warren Augustine worked as an employed private hire driver for Data Cars Ltd in 2016. He averaged 34.8 hours a week, fewer than typical full-time drivers. To access the company’s booking and dispatch system, every driver paid the same fixed weekly “circuit fee” of £148, regardless of hours worked.

Mr Augustine argued that the flat fee placed him at a disadvantage because, spread across fewer working hours, it cost him more per hour and reduced his effective hourly take-home pay more than it did for a full-time comparator.

The Employment Tribunal dismissed the claim, including on the basis that the fee was imposed to generate business revenue rather than solely because he worked part-time. The Employment Appeal Tribunal and Court of Appeal did not grant him relief, although the Court of Appeal was divided over whether the law required part-time status to be the sole cause of the treatment.

The Supreme Court’s Decision

In a unanimous judgment delivered on 12 August 2026, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal. It held that part-time status need not be the sole cause, or even the main cause of less favourable treatment. It is enough that being part-time is an effective cause: a factor that materially influences the treatment.

The Court therefore rejected the restrictive “sole ground” approach previously associated with McMenemy v Capita Business Services Ltd. It also made clear that an employer cannot answer a claim simply by pointing to another commercial reason for the measure. Where part-time status is an effective cause of the disadvantage, the Part-time Workers Regulations are engaged unless the treatment can be objectively justified.

The practical importance of the judgment lies in the wider test that tribunals must now apply. A policy that is facially neutral and imposed for genuine business reasons can still fall within the Part-time Workers Regulations, if working part-time materially contributes to the disadvantage.

What Employers Must Reconsider

  • Audit flat-rate costs and thresholds: Review fixed fees, uniform deductions, minimum contribution levels, attendance requirements and qualifying thresholds. Model their effect per hour, per shift and as a proportion of earnings for different working patterns.
  • Test substance, not just wording: Ask whether a rule that applies to everyone leaves part-time workers worse off in practice. Formal consistency is not the same as comparable treatment.
  • Revisit pay and benefits: Check bonuses, allowances, pensions, private medical cover, overtime triggers, leave, training budgets and promotion criteria. Decide whether pro-rating, or another proportionate adjustment, is needed.
  • Strengthen objective-justification records: Identify the legitimate business aim, consider less disadvantageous alternatives and retain evidence showing why the chosen measure is necessary and proportionate. Cost or administrative convenience alone may be difficult to defend.
  • Improve governance: Build part-time impact checks into policy approval, reward reviews and workforce-change projects. Train HR, payroll and line managers to identify indirect disadvantages and respond consistently to requests for reasons.
  • Review historic exposure: Prioritise longstanding arrangements affecting deductions, benefits or access to opportunities, and take advice before making corrective changes or communicating with affected workers.

The Employer Takeaway

Augustine changes the risk analysis. Employers should no longer ask only whether a policy was introduced because someone works part-time.

The better questions are whether part-time status materially contributes to the disadvantage, whether a comparable full-time worker is better off, and whether the difference can be supported by a carefully evidenced, proportionate justification.