holidays

Our popular columnist, Steve Herbert, Head of Benefits Strategy at Howden Employee Benefits & Wellbeing, explores whether a 4 day working week would work for the UK

It is no secret that some countries and their leaders have dealt with the coronavirus pandemic better than others, and New Zealand’s Jacinda Arden is a clear favourite to emerge from the crisis with the most improved global reputation.

 

Arden and her government reacted quickly to the crisis, aimed to eradicate rather than restrict the virus, and still managed to evoke a feeling of compassion and sympathy when she spoke to her nation.  The result for her country has been significant, with only 22 pandemic deaths so far recorded.

 

And it’s Arden and New Zealand too that are now proposing one of the most radical policies to help reduce the economic impact post-crisis.  Recently she spoke publicly about the possible adoption of a four-day working week in her country to boost domestic tourism.

 

But there is so much more to the proposal than tourism alone.  And accordingly many employers across the globe are currently considering the benefits or otherwise of such an approach, and in the United Kingdom there has been some recent cross-party pressure to encourage the Government to consider this option too.

 

Why now of all times?

Before proceeding further, we probably need to ask if this idea – in the teeth of an economic crisis the like of which none of us have ever witnessed – is one that UK employers should currently be considering?

 

It’s a valid challenge.  At the time of writing the nation is seeking a collective return to work after more than a quarter of a year of economic hiatus, and whilst also adhering to the not inconsiderable challenges of social distancing.  So the prospect of also returning the nation to a shorter working week – but at the same weekly wage paid to the employee – might seem like a wildly unnecessary left-wing fantasy.  And this at a time when resources are thinly stretched and the focus of many employers is understandably elsewhere.

 

Yet the truth is that now might be the ideal time to look at the introduction of this idea.  Times of great change – and even greater challenges – often demand innovation.  Or to borrow from an overused (but accurate) saying, necessity is indeed the mother of invention.

 

So let’s aim to approach this with an open mind, and consider if this really could be a beneficial step for employers and the nation.

 

Who benefits?

Supporters of a four-day week suggest that this is an idea with no obvious losers.

 

One of the most high-profile advocates of this approach is businessman Andrew Barnes.  Barnes is the Founder of corporate trustee company based in New Zealand, Perpetual Guardian, and it was his idea to steer that organisation towards operating a four-day week.

 

His thinking was driven by the realisation that many employees admit in surveys to only being productive for just a few hours each day.  As Barnes explains in this video, he was reading an article on a flight which suggested that;

 

“Britons were only productive for two and a half hours a day, and Canadians for only one and a half hours a day”

 

Barnes then wondered how productive his own employees actually were.  He thought about what might be driving such a low output on the working day, and concluded that at least some of the pressures were probably personal ones that were interrupting the daily work routine.

The next step however was a significant leap of positive thinking.

 

If his company “gave” each member of staff one extra free day per week to deal with their personal pressures at home, would the resultant increase in their output over the remaining four days off-set the loss of one day’s work?  His thinking here was informed by the assumption that if his employees were indeed only being productive for less than three hours a day, the extra effort made over the remaining four days to achieve at least parity in output would not be that significant.

 

And Barnes was proved right.  The productivity of the company improved in a trial period by 20%.  And a similar exercise by Microsoft in Japan in 2019 found an even better improvement in output, with productivity in that case increasing by nearly 40%.

 

But of course the positive effects of this change in employment practice are very much wider than just an improvement to the bottom-line.  Lower stress levels, better job satisfaction, more engagement, and increased loyalty to the employer are all obvious outputs of such an exercise.

 

And then there are wider economic and social implications to consider too.  Less travel is of course going to be better for the environment.  More family time is probably better for society as a whole, and (as Arden correctly identified) also likely to result in higher domestic leisure and tourism spending too.

 

A final – and not unimportant point – here.  This extra flexibility in the working week will probably enable many more workers with family and/or caring responsibilities to remain-in or return-to the workplace.  Since the primary carer in a family is often a woman, this move might also help reduce gender pay-gaps over time too.

 

So it looks like a win-win as far as these two trials go.

 

It’s happened before

Unusual as this approach might seem, it’s hardly without historical precedent.  After all working hours have reduced dramatically over the last 200 years.  In the early 1800s a working day of 16 hours was not unusual, and that for at least 6 days per week.  Over the years those hours have massively reduced in response to political campaigning, social pressures, and the increased wealth of the nation.

 

And in 1914 – on the other side of the Atlantic – Henry Ford famously reduced the working hours of his employees, and noticed a resultant rise in productivity in return.  The bottom line is that a four-day week may not be as outlandish a proposal as it might first appear.

 

Any obvious issues?

So there is certainly much merit in the proposals.  So what’s stopping employers embracing this apparent utopia?  Below are just some initial thoughts (and certainly not an exhaustive list) for employers to consider.

 

Firstly it should be noted that a four-day week might not be suitable for all employment types, and particularly where daily working hours are limited by law.  That might immediately exclude some employers and/or sections of the working population.

 

It’s also worth highlighting that although the principle of a four-day week is very simple, the practical steps to get there (including measuring the success or otherwise of any trial period) are potentially complex and time consuming.  Employers might currently be lacking in the capacity to look at such issues given the very real day-to-day challenges of post-lockdown Britain.

 

It’s also important to mention that there remains a significant question mark over how long the upswing in worker goodwill and resultant increased productivity will last.  With any such improvement in terms and conditions there is likely to be a cross-over point when worker expectations change, and the right to a four-day week becomes a “given” rather than a perceived extra benefit.

 

Finally, and certainly not least, it should be made clear that the introduction of a four-day week is probably not within the gift of any government to provide just at the moment.  Indeed Jacinda Arden has already said;

 

“I’ve heard lots of people suggesting we should have a four-day week, ultimately that really sits between employers and employees.”

 

It follows that employers looking at this route might well have to do so without the benefit of a government-sponsored framework to support them in delivering this new standard.

 

So what’s my view?

Ultimately a four-day week sounds like – and probably is – a huge step forward for workers and their families, and also represents a potentially significant set of wins for their employers too.

 

That said, it’s my personal view that the boost in productivity will probably dissipate over time, and will certainly reduce more quickly if a large wave of employers in any given industry all suddenly introduce a broadly similar policy and a four-day week becomes “the norm” in that sector.  So it follows that the employers that move earliest are likely to be the biggest winners from shortening the working week.  If anything this should encourage employers that are capable of introducing this change to act that much more quickly given the economic challenges of the moment.

 

So, as outlandish as the idea might initially sound, I suspect a four-day working week might well be an idea that is actively being explored by both employers and governments in months and years immediately ahead.

 

Steve Herbert is Head of Benefits Strategy at Howden Employee Benefits & Wellbeing