A group of employees in heated discussion, one holding a 'HELP' sign, indicates workplace stress.

Written by Thomas Beale, Partner and Head of the Bullying and Harassment team at Bolt Burdon Kemp. 

The recent reforms to employment legislation have strengthened employee protections in meaningful ways. Among these, the Worker Protection Act 2023 is a notable addition to the Equality Act 2010, compelling employers to take active steps against sexual harassment. While this measure is welcome, another pressing issue remains overlooked: workplace bullying. Without specific protections or a clear definition of bullying under current legislation, employees subjected to such behaviours are often left without adequate legal recourse.

The Legal Landscape: Sexual Harassment vs. Workplace Bullying

Sexual harassment is distinctly recognised by the Equality Act 2010, which defines it as any “unwanted conduct of a sexual nature” that infringes on an individual’s dignity or creates a hostile or offensive work environment. Victims of sexual harassment may seek redress through the Employment Tribunal, where employers can face a “compensation uplift” of up to 25% if they are found to have failed in their duty to protect employees.

However, workplace bullying, unless tied to a protected characteristic like age or race, falls outside the Act’s scope. This creates a significant gap for general bullying cases, which often lack such ties to discrimination. Bullying encompasses a range of behaviours, both overt and covert, that may include:

  • Engaging in ridicule or derogatory comments;
  • Excessively punishing or criticising;
  • Deliberately undermining effort;
  • Using intimidating or hostile language;
  • Withholding training or career progression; and
  • Assigning unfair workloads.

Victims of bullying that does not target a protected characteristic often find that current laws offer limited support, pushing them to pursue other legal avenues that may not fully address their experiences.

The normalisation of bullying behaviours has trivialised their impact, even as they lead to lasting psychological harm. For many, seeking justice is a crucial step in recovering from these experiences. Unfortunately, without clear bullying protections, available legal channels remain limited and often ineffective.

Using the Protection from Harassment Act 1997

One option for victims is filing a claim under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 in the civil courts. This Act allows for holding employers “vicariously liable” for the conduct of their employees. However, meeting the criteria is challenging. The behaviour must be “oppressive and unacceptable,” and courts have further restricted this to behaviour that meets a criminal-level threshold. For many workplace bullying cases, this high bar makes achieving justice under the Act unrealistic.

Filing Claims in Negligence

Another potential course is a negligence claim, pursued if an employer has been made aware of bullying but failed to act. This, too, presents challenges: proving what an employer knew and when is often complex, and obtaining witness statements from colleagues can be difficult as they may fear retaliation. Without substantial corroborative evidence, victims may struggle to succeed with this approach.

The Path Forward: Why Anti-Bullying Legislation is Needed

While recent employment reforms have made strides in addressing sexual harassment, they have left workplace bullying largely unaddressed. Victims find the current legal avenues complex and restrictive, and the lack of a statutory definition leaves uncertainty about what behaviour qualifies as bullying.

Advocating for dedicated bullying protections is essential to ensure clarity, consistency, and support for those affected by workplace incivility. To create a safer, more supportive workplace culture, anti-harassment laws need to evolve beyond a narrow focus, protecting employees from all forms of workplace abuse. Addressing bullying directly through bespoke legislation would represent a significant step towards more respectful and inclusive workplaces.