Research has revealed that millions of UK workers are paying more tax than they need to, with experts suggesting that employers could (and should) play a much bigger role in helping staff understand their taxes.
According to recent figures, around 5.6 million UK workers and pensioners overpaid income tax last year, with HMRC collecting an estimated £3.5 billion more than it should have. On average, affected taxpayers overpaid around £625, although some people have managed to claim back refunds worth several thousand pounds.
While tax codes are ultimately managed by HMRC, many employees assume that if tax is being deducted through PAYE, it must be right. In reality, small changes in employment throughout the fiscal year can result in workers paying too much tax for months or even years.
Why are so many people overpaying tax?
The majority of overpayments come from incorrect PAYE tax codes.
A tax code tells employers how much Income Tax should be taken from an employee’s wages before they are paid. If the code is right, employees may end up paying more tax than they need to without realising it.
Errors commonly occur when someone:
- Starts a new job.
- Has more than one employer.
- Changes salary during the year.
- Receives company benefits, such as private medical insurance or a company car.
- Starts receiving a pension alongside employment.
In many cases, HMRC may not have the latest information, meaning tax deductions continue based on old records.
Many employees don’t realise anything is wrong
One of the biggest issues is that there is no automatic notification every time someone overpays tax.
Although HMRC carries out reconciliations after the end of the tax year and may issue a rebate where needed, employees shouldn’t assume they’ll be contacted straight away. Many only discover an error after checking their Personal Tax Account or speaking with an accountant.
That means millions of working people across the UK could be unnecessarily handing over a big chunk of their monthly take-home pay to HMRC without knowing it.
Employers have an opportunity to improve financial wellbeing
Over the past decade, it has become more common for employers to invest in employee wellbeing. However, finances can be a huge driver of stress, and yet financial wellbeing is often overlooked.
Education initiatives, reminders for staff to check their payslips and understand their tax codes are all elements that could help employees spot issues faster.
But for businesses, improving financial literacy doesn’t just benefit employees’ wallets.
Lower financial stress has been linked to improved productivity, making tax awareness another way employers can support their workforce.
How employees can check whether they’re paying too much tax
Employees who think they may have overpaid tax should:
- Look at the tax code on their latest payslip and check it aligns with their current situation
- Log into their HMRC Personal Tax Account through Government Gateway to review their income and tax records.
- Look out for a P800 Tax Calculation after the end of the tax year.
- Remember that tax refunds can generally be claimed for up to four previous tax years if they have overpaid.
Commenting on the findings, a spokesperson for Pie Tax said:
“Many people believe that because tax is deducted automatically through PAYE, it must always be right. Unfortunately, that’s not always the case. Switching jobs, taking on a second role or receiving workplace benefits can all affect your taxes, and if you’re not paying attention, you could end up overpaying for a long time.”
They added:
“We encourage everyone to review their tax code regularly rather than assuming everything is right. Employers can also play an important role by encouraging staff to understand how their tax works, what to look for and where to go if something doesn’t look right.”