Stunning daytime view of Big Ben and Palace of Westminster in London, UK.

Chief Executive Neil Carberry urges collaboration and caution following new Pensions Commission announcement

The Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) has responded to the government’s announcement of a new Pensions Commission with a warning that any future reform must involve employers as equal partners in the process, not passive recipients of policy change.

Neil Carberry, Chief Executive of the REC, praised the success of automatic enrolment introduced in 2012, which saw employers and employees contribute jointly to workplace pensions, but cautioned against unilaterally altering the current framework without meaningful dialogue with businesses.

“There is no doubt that sustainable pension saving matters, and one of the great successes of the last 20 years is the consensus-based introduction of automatic enrolment and employer contributions from 2012,” Carberry said.

“But that change wasn’t free – businesses have stepped up to pay more in partnership with their employees. Any review to this settlement needs to be done with business – not to them. The jury is out on whether we can repeat the good work of the Turner Commission, which was based on deep partnership with business that made it successful.”

Carberry expressed concern that the new Commission could signal further financial pressure on employers already struggling with a range of rising employment costs. These include the April hike in National Insurance, rapid increases in the minimum wage, and proposed changes to employment rights, which many businesses fear could bring new levels of bureaucracy.

“Employment costs in the UK have been rising, and we must be a competitive and attractive place to create jobs,” he said.

“With technology reshaping our labour market, a huge raid on employers in the form of National Insurance rises this April, pay driven up by minimum wage rises of a quarter in three years, and the threat of a hugely bureaucratic approach to employment rights in the form of the Government’s current Bill, firms are already deeply concerned.”

Carberry warned that, without a clear commitment to collaboration and a phased, consultative approach, the new Commission could risk eroding employer support—the very factor that underpinned the original success of automatic enrolment.

“If the government wants to drive up business investment and thereby economic growth, firms need the capital to do that,” he concluded.

“Many business leaders will see this as another potential increase in costs – to be successful, the Commission and the DWP will need to ease those fears by moving slowly, working with business and remembering that the success of automatic enrolment is in the support it generated from employers across the country.”

The REC is expected to monitor the development of the Pensions Commission closely and continue pushing for a balanced and collaborative approach that supports both long-term retirement security and economic competitiveness.