A new study by Protecht, suppliers of risk management software and solutions, has revealed the corporate mistakes that cost UK businesses the most in fines.
Using data from the Good Jobs First Violation Tracker, Protecht analysed over 36,000 corporate fines from 2020 – 2024, to discover what the most common types of corporate violations are, and which are the most costly to UK businesses.
The research found that the most expensive corporate mistake is bribery. Penalties for this type of violation have cost UK businesses £2.1 billion during the five year period analysed.
All types of competition related violations combined account for £3 billion worth of corporate fines. The average fine for competition related offences is £26.1 million.
Employment related offences are the most common type of violation that companies get fined for. There have been over 4,000 violations a year on average.
Bribery is the most costly corporate violation
|
Cost of Corporate Fines Ranked by Violation |
||||
|
Rank |
Violation |
Total Cost of Fines |
Number of Fines |
Average Cost per Fine |
|
1 |
Bribery |
£2,100,304,322 |
7 |
£300,043,475 |
|
2 |
Investor Protection Violation |
£737,346,777 |
31 |
£23,785,380 |
|
3 |
Price-Fixing or Anti-Competitive Practices |
£720,785,625 |
72 |
£10,010,911 |
|
4 |
Consumer Protection Violation |
£711,596,046 |
3,745 |
£190,012 |
|
5 |
Anti-Money-Laundering Deficiencies |
£587,902,002 |
1,724 |
£341,010 |
|
6 |
Banking Violation |
£313,793,037 |
6 |
£52,298,840 |
|
7 |
Internal Controls Deficiency |
£306,721,700 |
8 |
£38,340,213 |
|
8 |
Tax Violations |
£246,250,141 |
1,181 |
£208,510 |
|
9 |
Labour Standards Violation |
£232,431,844 |
20,288 |
£11,457 |
|
10 |
Energy Market Violation |
£216,038,455 |
35 |
£6,172,527 |
The research from Protecht analysed 51 different corporate violations, revealing that bribery violations have cost UK companies the highest sum in fines since the turn of the decade. These violations have been punished with £2.1 billion worth of fines, at an average fine of £300 million per offence.
Fines for investor protection violations added up to £737 million, the second highest total for any individual offence. Investor protection violations are issued with an average fine of £23.8 million. Of all of the violations with 10+ fines issued in the five year period analysed, investor protection violations had the highest average fine.
The third most costly mistake is price-fixing or anti-competitive practices. These have an average fine of £10 million, totalling £721 million in fines.
Also in the top five are consumer protection violations, and anti-money-laundering deficiencies, with fines totalling £712 million and £588 million respectively.
Labour standards violations are the most fined violations
|
Number of Corporate Fines Ranked by Violation |
||||
|
Rank |
Violation |
Number of Fines |
Total Cost of Fines |
Average Cost per Fine |
|
1 |
Labour Standards Violation |
20,288 |
£232,431,844 |
£11,457 |
|
2 |
Workplace Safety/Health Violation |
5,425 |
£210,923,214 |
£38,880 |
|
3 |
Consumer Protection Violation |
3,745 |
£711,596,046 |
£190,012 |
|
4 |
Anti-Money-Laundering Deficiencies |
1,724 |
£587,902,002 |
£341,010 |
|
5 |
Pension Plan Violation |
1,295 |
£14,342,398 |
£11,075 |
|
6 |
Tax Violations |
1,181 |
£246,250,141 |
£208,510 |
|
7 |
Care Quality Violation |
768 |
£14,236,961 |
£18,538 |
|
8 |
Accounting Fraud or Deficiencies |
359 |
£169,287,013 |
£471,552 |
|
9 |
Environmental Violation |
344 |
£6,955,692 |
£20,220 |
|
10 |
Legal Services Violation |
213 |
£1,652,001 |
£7,756 |
Although bribery offences are the most costly corporate violations, the most common are labour standards violations. During the five year period analysed, there have been over 20,000 fines issued for this type of violation. UK businesses are penalised on average £11,000 for this type of offence.
The second most common offence was workplace safety/health violations. There have been more 1,000 fines a year for these offences, with an average fine of £39,000.
There have been over 3,700 fines issued for consumer protection violations. Fines for this type of offence have surpassed £712 million in the last five years, averaging at £190,000 per violation.
Anti-money-laundering deficiencies are the fourth most common with 1,724, followed by pension plan violations at 1,295.
Competition related offences cost UK businesses £616 million a year
|
Cost of Corporate Fines Ranked by Offence Group |
|||
|
Rank |
Offence Group |
Total Cost of Fines |
Average Cost per Fine |
|
1 |
Competition |
£3,078,816,402 |
£26,091,664 |
|
2 |
Financial |
£2,429,693,707 |
£733,160 |
|
3 |
Consumer Protection |
£1,318,980,608 |
£302,796 |
|
4 |
Environment |
£296,159,563 |
£405,698 |
|
5 |
Employment |
£271,862,423 |
£12,594 |
|
6 |
Safety |
£220,953,244 |
£39,372 |
|
7 |
Healthcare |
£14,236,961 |
£16,969 |
Protecht’s research also categorised the 51 types of violations into seven categories, to reveal which groups of offences are most costly. UK businesses are fined on average £616 million a year for competition related offences. The average fine for competition related violations is £26.1 million, the highest of the seven groups analysed.
From 2020 – 2024, financial related offences had the second highest total cost accumulated in fines at £2.4 billion. These offences also have the second highest average fine fee at £733,000.
The third most costly fines have been for consumer protection related offences. These violations have totaled over £1.3 billion in fines, with an average cost of £303,000 per fine.
Employment related offences have the lowest average fine per violation at £12,600.
59% of corporate offences are employment related
|
Number of Corporate Fines Ranked by Offence Group |
|||
|
Rank |
Offence Group |
Number of Fines |
Most Common Type of Offence |
|
1 |
Employment |
21,587 |
Labour Standards Violation |
|
2 |
Safety |
5,612 |
Workplace Safety/Health Violation |
|
3 |
Consumer Protection |
4,356 |
Consumer Protection Violation |
|
4 |
Financial |
3,314 |
Anti-Money-Laundering Deficiencies |
|
5 |
Healthcare |
839 |
Care Quality Violation |
|
6 |
Environment |
730 |
Environmental Violation |
|
7 |
Competition |
118 |
Price-Fixing or Anti-Competitive Practices |
Of the seven different categories analysed, the most common type of corporate offences in the last five years have been employment related.
There have been over 21,000 fines in the last five years handed out to UK businesses for employment violations. 94% of employment related offences are for labour standards violations. 59% of all recorded offences were employment related offences.
The second most common type of offences are safety related. 15% of all fines were issued for safety related offences, the most common type being workplace safety/health violations.
12% of all violations are consumer protection related, followed by 9% for financial offences, and 2% each for healthcare, and environment related violations.
Although competition related offences accumulated the highest cost in fines, they only make up 0.3% of all recorded violations.
Protecht’s VP of Risk & Compliance, Jared Siddle, commented on the findings of the study:
“From bribery to money laundering, the financial and reputational costs of non-compliance in the UK are huge. The data shows that while labour violations are the most frequent, it’s the competition and corruption breaches that break the bank. Too often, risk is seen as an operational inconvenience. But it should be front and centre for boards and executives, because that one oversight can cost millions.”
The full details of the study by Protecht can be found at https://www.protechtgroup.com/en-gb/blog/the-most-costly-corporate-mistakes