Written by Jonathan Evans, CEO of workforce strategy consultancy Discovery ADR.

I have worked in recruitment for over 30 years. In that time, I’ve seen the industry at its best and its worst. I’ve seen recruiters change lives, help businesses scale, and create opportunities that transform careers. I’ve also seen how the structures and incentives that underpin the industry can drive behaviours that damage trust, waste money, and harm both businesses and candidates.

Recruitment has always been business-critical. The right people accelerate growth and build resilience; the wrong people create risk and slow progress. For decades, companies have turned to recruitment agencies to bridge that gap. And let’s be clear: there are many outstanding professionals in recruitment. They know their markets, they care about their clients and candidates, and they often work tirelessly to deliver.

The issue is not the people. The issue is the model.

The Flaw in “No Win, No Fee”

Most agencies still operate on a contingency basis: they only get paid if they place someone. On the surface, this looks like a safe, client-friendly option. But in practice it creates behaviours that rarely serve either businesses or candidates well.

When reward only comes with placement, the incentive is to focus on speed and volume. Recruiters are measured on CVs sent rather than on whether the hire will thrive. Businesses, wary of being let down, push fees down to minimise risk. Agencies, under pressure, chase volume to protect their margins. The cycle repeats, trust erodes, and everyone loses.

Even the best recruiters find themselves working within a system that rewards short-term wins over long-term success.

When Incentives Go Too Far

Sometimes the model pushes behaviour beyond inefficiency into practices that are ethically questionable. One example is the deliberate poaching of candidates shortly after they’ve been placed, simply to earn a second fee for filling the same role again.

During an ATS demonstration I attended, a supplier proudly showcased the flexibility of custom fields. For one agency client, they had even built in a “poach by date” field. The fact that such a field existed, and was talked about so casually, was deeply concerning. It normalised the idea that extracting people from placements is a legitimate commercial tactic.

It is practices like these that explain why recruitment has the reputation it does. The industry is tarnished not by its people, but by the behaviours incentivised by a model that puts fees ahead of ethics, client trust, and candidate welfare.

Why the Model Doesn’t Work in 2025

The weaknesses of contingency have always been there. But in today’s environment they are impossible to ignore.

Skills shortages persist. Employers across the UK continue to report hard-to-fill vacancies, particularly in engineering, healthcare, technology and professional services. Every hire matters, and the cost of repeating the process when someone leaves is too great.

Candidate expectations have shifted. Employees now want more than a payslip. They look for values, flexibility, purpose and development opportunities. Traditional processes, driven by speed, don’t assess for these factors. Candidates are matched on skills alone, not on motivation or cultural alignment. It’s little wonder that research shows as many as 40% of hires fail within 18 months.

Technology has moved ahead. AI sourcing, behavioural profiling and employer branding tools provide deeper insight than database searches ever could. But contingency models discourage investment. Many agencies stick to old processes and mass outreach because they can’t risk spending time on methods that might not result in a fee.

And let’s not forget the limits of the CV. A CV is a statement of information, sometimes fact, sometimes spin. I’ve never seen one that says “I did this role for four years but I wasn’t very good at it.” Past experience is no guarantee of future success, especially when hiring for what the business will need in two or three years’ time. Future-ready hiring requires calibrated assessments of capability, potential and stretch benchmarked in line with an organisational strategy – not just a scan of career history.

Return on investment is under the microscope. Boards don’t object to paying for recruitment when it delivers. But they cannot justify spending on hires that fail and destabilise teams.

In this climate, “no win, no fee” feels less like protection and more like a gamble.

Why In-House Isn’t the Whole Answer

Frustrated with agencies, many companies have built internal talent acquisition teams. On the surface, this feels sensible: reduce reliance on external providers, control costs, and retain knowledge in-house. In reality, the picture is more complex.

The drive to cut costs is often the biggest motivator, yet few organisations measure whether this approach is genuinely more cost-effective. Once you factor in failed hires, time-to-productivity, and the burden of permanent overheads, the savings are often minimal. Audits frequently show that any financial benefit is quickly eroded by the risks.

Companies also underestimate the resource required to run an effective in-house function. Today’s candidate market is more vocal than ever, quick to share poor experiences that can damage an employer brand. Without proper investment, internal teams can struggle to balance the needs of the business with protecting candidate experience.

Even established in-house teams face clear limitations. They are often stretched across too many fronts and lack the market knowledge and expertise to move from graduate intakes to niche technical hires and senior appointments, whilst leaving little time for the basics, such as giving candidates feedback or even acknowledging an application. Lack of feedback remains one of the biggest complaints from jobseekers and a major source of reputational damage for employers.

These teams are also bound by office hours, while candidates increasingly expect engagement during evenings and weekends. And although most track time-to-hire, more meaningful measures quality of hire, retention, time-to-productivity, and candidate experience are frequently overlooked.  True cost-per-hire is rarely attributed as internal teams are a fixed overhead.  Measuring this properly would give board rooms a very different view of the effectiveness of their hiring processes.

In-house functions may offer some control, but rarely the flexibility to scale up and down with shifting demand. That is why many organisations still look outward for support. The real question is not whether external partners are needed – they are, but which type of partner will align best with the long-term needs of the business.

Time for Change

This is not about criticising recruiters. Many are excellent at what they do, often despite the constraints of the system. It is about recognising that the traditional contingency model is no longer fit for purpose. It incentivises the wrong behaviours, creates mistrust, and in some cases actively damages both businesses and candidates.

Recruitment done well is invaluable. It transforms organisations, brings in future leaders, and strengthens resilience. Done badly, it wastes money, undermines teams, and damages careers.

After three decades in the industry, my view is simple: businesses deserve better. They need recruitment solutions that are aligned with strategy, not transactions. They need quality, retention and resilience, not just CVs. And they need partners whose incentives match their success, not partners trapped in a model that puts short-term fees above long-term value.

In 2025, it is time for the industry to evolve.

 

About the author

Jonathan Evans is the Founder and CEO of Discovery ADR, an award-winning consultancy specialising in workforce strategy, leadership development, and organisational resilience. With over 25 years of experience helping companies, from scaling SMEs to global PLCs, Jonathan advises business leaders on how to build people strategies that drive performance, reduce risk, and sustain growth. He is a passionate advocate for resilience-by-design and transforming people risk into strategic advantage.