Jo Lyon, Managing Director, Talking Talent

With COVID-19 came the advent of remote working which offered many of us a unique look into our co-workers’ lives over the last 20 months. While we were left with little choice but to connect digitally, and the regular video calls were not always our favourite activity, in many ways our remote conversations brought us closer than ever before. We’ve caught glimpses of wedding photographs, met each other’s children and pets, seen our colleagues’ taste in interiors and, above all, shared our hopes and fears amidst a worrying, ongoing global pandemic. And now it’s potentially all happening again with new government guidance on working from home being reintroduced. Between the mundane and the unprecedented, there are opportunities to connect and use our often undervalued ‘soft skills’ such as empathy. Unfortunately, it appears that these opportunities were not always taken.

With 2020 and 2021 being two of the most emotionally testing years in recent memory, with the lines between work and home blurred, sympathy and understanding has never been more important as employees across England return to working from home – from management interactions with staff and vice versa. In recent research[1] however, it was found that this type of support failed to meet expectations. Regarding managers in particular, anecdotal feedback found that real-life support fell short of expectations, with the most frequent issue identified as a ‘lack of understanding or empathy’.

Of course, the extra pressures put on managers should not be underestimated, over the past 18 months, many had to step up to roles that were both strategic and pastoral while juggling their own personal pressures such as caring for family, home schooling and even loneliness, illness, and bereavement. Understandably this was overwhelming and potentially had a trickle-down effect to other staff members who could not look upwards for support, leading to frustration and even resentment. With many diverse circumstances at play, was our empathy another victim of COVID-19?

Why we need empathy in the workplace

The ability to be compassionate as a human and connect with people around us is vital, professionally, and personally. On a professional level, research has shown that empathy leads to happier and more productive employees with increased loyalty and retention.

At its core, empathy in the workplace is about treating people, as people; working alongside each other as individuals who are managing non-work-related pressures all the time and understanding how this can impact work. It should come naturally to many of us, but after decades of toxic work environments, corporate mindsets, and expectations of leaving our personal lives at the office door, our expectations may be skewed. Additionally, with burnout levels skyrocketing, long working hours, high targets, and ineffective management training – a once simple instinct can seem like a minefield.

It is time for an overhaul. Individuals who demonstrate more empathy are skilled at understanding a situation from a neutral perspective and can respond in a fair, balanced way that considers the nuances of people’s lives. A loss of empathy is the loss of an incredibly important skill, ‘soft’ or otherwise and as England moves back to government guidelines to work from home it is essential we don’t forgo our empathy once more.

Businesses may well benefit if employees left their personal lives at the door, but we all know that as a diverse, multi-faceted population, we don’t (and shouldn’t) operate in that way. We should feel confident about bringing our whole selves to the workplace. We need to nurture an open working culture where everyone can share their struggles and benefit from support.  So, how can we do that?

A culture with empathy at the core

In much the same way that empathy has been eroded over time – bringing it back to the workplace is a longer process with no overnight solution. At the core of a more empathetic workplace is one that fosters an open culture where people are valued for their diverse needs and talents. Unfortunately, this won’t happen without ongoing discussion, coaching and frank evaluation. This culture is one that embodies the notion of psychological safety which means having the space to air your feelings without fear of repercussions, whether that is feelings of discrimination or being overwhelmed by both work and personal pressures. Having this at work means that workers can air issues before they grow and cause bigger issues, such as burnout, down the line. We should think about the basic act of empathy as a building block of this psychological safety because it is an important part of knowing our feelings are taken seriously, and without it the safety can’t exist.

In fact, many terms you hear a lot in the discussion of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) in the workplace are dependent on the ability to be empathetic. Allyship is an essential part of DEI and is a key example of the need for empathy, how can we hope to advocate for others in the workplace if we don’t try to understand their experiences and emotions?

The two-way street

Of course, every workplace comprises people of different ages and professional levels. Whether you’re a manager or not, you’re likely to have felt multiple pressures from all angles over the last couple of years. The expectation can be that managers should pick up pastoral care and balance professional responsibilities without expecting it in return, but is that really an empathetic culture? In my view this adds pressure to some groups which can only worsen existing issues. Without mutual respect and empathy, across the hierarchy, your workplace is doomed to exclude some people from adequate emotional care.

We must remember that at the centre of empathy is the ability to put ourselves in other people’s shoes – often people who have very different experiences to us. While there are always similarities, the differences between an employee and a manager can be perceived as stark. When we talk about empathy, we must leave roles out of it and create a place where mutual respect and empathy is a given. The workplace is changed by the actions of many, not few. The culture is built by them too.

Regardless of the changing COVID-19 restrictions and the nature of a ‘workplace’ becoming more abstract with each iteration, lack of empathy needs to be firmly left in 2020/21 as we adapt to our surroundings and colleagues. Across levels, we can all benefit from more empathy and understanding at work.

[1] [1] Research conducted by Talking Talent – responses gathered by an internal CRM survey in Feb 2021