Written by Terry Lees, People & Change Lead, NFP
The post-pandemic world has radically changed how we work. Hybrid and remote work patterns have challenged traditional assumptions of visibility and control, while monitoring has crept in as a quick fix. Dashboards, trackers and surveillance tools seem to provide a sense of certainty in uncertain times. The proliferation of data to measure our everyday lives continues at a great pace, but at what cost? The pursuit of output erodes our trust and limits our creativity.
The Human Cost
At its core, this debate is not about technology. It is about people. The decision to monitor is never neutral; it sends a message. Done poorly, it tells employees: ‘We don’t believe you unless we can see you’. Weakening trust then results in a negative impact on employee performance, inclusion and wellbeing.
Organisations are right to expect results, but performance should never come at the expense of culture. Inclusion isn’t a soft extra; it is a multiplier of performance. Trust fuels commitment and surveillance fuels caution. Remove psychological safety and you don’t just stifle innovation; you shut down the very core of human potential.
Accountability Without Intrusion
The balance between oversight and autonomy is the real test. Holding people to account makes sense but tracking their every move does not.
Such protocols rightly come with a health warning. Positive intent aside, what outcomes are we really looking for? The notion that ‘what gets measured, gets done’ still holds true, but does the same rule apply to monitoring our movements? We all expect to be evaluated against performance targets, but is it always necessary to track how those targets are achieved?
Results Over Methods
Does it really matter how or where we complete our work, provided role expectations are met? There is an imperative to align with organisational values and behaviours. Beyond that, we should have the autonomy to work in ways that enable, empower and elevate our approach. Psychologically safe environments consistently prove to be performance-enhancing.
Transparency as the Key to Acceptable Monitoring
There is also a fine line between using data to drive performance without crossing into intrusion. Employees are more accepting when monitoring is transparent. This approach means they understand what is measured, why it matters and how it will be used. Anything less breeds suspicion.
GDPR sets the legal baseline, but culture is shaped by ethics. Just because a practice is lawful does not mean it is right. Monitoring that strips away dignity corrodes trust and, in time, reputation. HR leaders need to ask not only whether they can monitor, but why should they?
The Wellbeing Impact
Surveillance also has a tangible impact on wellbeing. Constant observation fuels anxiety, and shifts focus from creating value to ‘looking busy.’ That is not productivity; it is performance by fear.
Why Surveillance Threatens Talent Retention
Generational expectations make this risk even starker. Many younger employees, especially Gen Z, see excessive monitoring as a failure of leadership. In a competitive labour market, surveillance-heavy organisations will not be the employer of choice. The commercial risk is as real as the cultural one.
HR’s Strategic Role
This is where HR must play its part. Monitoring software cannot replace capable people management. It cannot motivate, coach or build commitment. HR leaders are guardians of organisational culture and the employee experience, but they also have a further commercial role to play. By working alongside their senior leadership teams, HR unlocks systems that strengthen culture and block anything that can corrode it.
Organisations face a choice. Continue down the path of surveillance, or embody inclusive leadership practice, creating environments where people are free to deliver outcomes in ways that work best for them.
If we want to understand what motivates employees, or what a good or bad day looks like for them, we don’t need another dashboard; we just need to ask them.