By Shaun Hogan, Senior Associate at Stevens & Bolton LLP

With the Government’s continued emphasis on returning to work, some employers may be considering whether toconduct their own COVID-19 testing for their employees to limit transmission of the virus at work. However, before doing so, employers should pause to consider whether this is the right policy to pursue.

What legal issues need to be considered?

An employer owes a duty of care on health and safety grounds to its employees to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the workplace is safe. Whilst testing may not be necessary to ensure the workplace is safe, it may help reassure employees.

As it relates to medical information, test results will amount to special category data under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Consequently, employers should follow guidance from the Information Commissioner’s Office, which recommendsemployersconsider whether testing is appropriate before gathering any such data. Specifically, employers should ask themselves to what extent testing will help make the workplace safe and whether there are alternative measures that could be put in placefirst to achieve a similar outcome. The GDPR also requires such data to be held securely and only for so long as it is necessary. Employers should therefore consider how, and for how long, it will store the results data.

Mandatory testing may also disproportionately affect certain employees and therefore employers should be aware of the potential for discrimination claims to arise. Targeting testing at employees who are considered at a high risk of contracting the virus may result in targeting disabled employees or older members of staff, leading to claims.

Can testing be compulsory?

Employees are obliged to follow reasonable management instructions. It is therefore likely that an employer could reasonably instruct an employee showing symptoms to be tested, as a way to protect other members of staff.

Where an employee does not exhibit signs of the virus, whether an instruction to be tested would be reasonable would depend on a number of factors. The employer would need to take into account the other measures that could adequately manage the risk of transmission. For instance, a workplace in which employees will struggle to socially distance or involves employees working in enclosed environments will more likely be able to justify imposing blanket testing. However, a better approach for most employers will be to encourage employees to consent to voluntary testing.

What if an employee refuses?

Where mandatory testing qualifies as a reasonable management instruction, it may be possible to take disciplinary action against an employee who refuses to take a test. However, before doing so, an employer should carefully consider whether there are any mitigating circumstances explaining the employee’s refusal. For example, if an employee refuses on medical grounds, taking disciplinary action could lead to claims of constructive unfair dismissal or even disability discrimination.

Employers should also considerwhat there is to gain by taking disciplinary action and whether it would be compatible with the company’s values.There is also potential reputational risk should an employee make the disciplinary action public, which there is no simple way to mitigate against.

What’s the right approach?

Whilst specific workplace considerations will apply, employers should generally look to limit testing to those who show symptoms of the virus orimplementing it only on a voluntary basis. Communication is key in providing comfort to employees that testing is in their interests, that their personal data will be handled sensitively and securely, and that they will not be penalised should they test positive.