man holding phone and sitting while putting left hand on his face

Employees should normally speak directly to their manager when calling in sick, but employers need to take a flexible approach when health conditions or other circumstances make a telephone conversation difficult.

That is the advice from HR software provider BrightHR following a renewed debate over how workers should report sickness absence.

The discussion follows comments from Sir Charlie Mayfield, former chairman of John Lewis, who was reported in The Times as calling for employees to contact their managers directly when illness prevents them from working.

BrightHR says a direct conversation can be valuable for both employers and employees, helping managers understand what support may be required, make arrangements for workloads and cover, and establish an indication of how long someone could be away.

However, it warns that such conversations need to be handled sensitively and should not leave employees feeling that they are being challenged over whether they are genuinely ill.

Alan Price, CEO at BrightHR, said:

“I agree with Sir Charlie about the value of a direct conversation when an employee is sick. A phone call is often the quickest and best way to understand what support an employee needs. It’s also an opportunity to talk about work that may need to be covered while they are off and likely timescales on return to work.

“But a sickness call should never feel like an interrogation. Managers should focus on welfare and practical arrangements. They should never imply that an employee is letting the team down or treat an absence as suspicious. The purpose of the call should be to listen, respect confidentiality and focus on what the employee needs.

“Employers should set clear and consistent absence-reporting rules, but they also need to use judgment. If an employee’s health condition makes a call difficult, or there is another good reason why they cannot call, then they should make alternative arrangements such as sending a text or email, or having a relative call in.”

Managers Need Training On Sickness Conversations

BrightHR believes employers should ensure managers understand how to respond when an employee reports that they are unable to work.

Rather than allowing an initial sickness notification to drift into an informal disciplinary conversation, managers should concentrate on the employee’s wellbeing, immediate practical arrangements and, where possible, an indication of likely timescales.

Employers should also agree an appropriate level of contact during longer periods of sickness absence. Too much contact could place unnecessary pressure on an employee, while no communication at all can leave people feeling unsupported and make planning a return to work more difficult.

Where appropriate, employers may also want to consider occupational health advice and reasonable adjustments.

Return-to-work discussions can provide an opportunity to identify whether additional support could help an employee resume their duties. Depending on the circumstances, this could include a phased return, amended working hours, lighter duties or additional check-ins.

Price added:

“If an employer stops all contact when an employee is off sick then they may feel abandoned. And the company loses the opportunity to put proper plans in place or discuss adjustments to help support them back to work. A conversation helps everyone, provided it is handled fairly and with respect.”

For employers, the message is therefore not simply about insisting on a telephone call. Clear sickness-reporting procedures can provide consistency, but managers also need sufficient discretion to recognise when an alternative method of communication is more appropriate.