Immigrants living in Europe and North America earn, on average, almost 18% less than native-born citizens — not because they are paid less for the same work, but because they face barriers to entering higher-paying jobs.
That’s the conclusion of a new study led by Professor Halil Sabanci of the Frankfurt School of Finance & Management, published in Nature. The research analysed data from 13.5 million workers across nine countries: Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, and the United States.
Limited Access to Better Jobs Drives the Gap
The analysis found an immigrant-native pay gap of 17.9% overall. Crucially, only a small portion of this disparity stems from unequal pay for the same role. Instead, the vast majority — around three-quarters of the gap — arises because immigrants are more likely to work in lower-paying industries, occupations, and companies.
Professor Sabanci explained:
“These findings shed new light on persistent pay disparities and have direct policy implications. While enforcing equal pay for equal work matters, the bigger challenge lies in opening access to higher-paying jobs. Addressing hiring bias and improving job-matching programmes may go much further.”
Country-by-Country Differences
The pay gap varied significantly between countries:
-
Spain (29.9%) and Canada (27.5%) showed the largest disparities.
-
Norway (20.3%), Germany (19.6%), France (18.9%), and the Netherlands (15.4%) had mid-level gaps.
-
The United States (10.6%), Denmark (9.2%), and Sweden (7.0%) recorded the smallest differences.
Progress in the Next Generation
For second-generation immigrants — the children of those who migrated — the gap is far smaller but still present. In Canada, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, and Sweden, researchers found the disparity dropped from 17.9% to 5.7%.
However, challenges remain, particularly for descendants of immigrants from Africa and the Middle East. When comparing workers in the same role for the same employer, the second-generation pay gap shrinks dramatically to just 1.1%, suggesting much greater parity once access barriers are removed.
Policy Implications
The study points to several strategies that could help narrow the divide, including:
-
Language training and skills development
-
Recognition of foreign qualifications
-
Improved job-matching and recruitment practices
-
Better access to education, job-relevant information, and professional networks
By tackling structural barriers and hiring biases, policymakers could help immigrants and their families not only achieve fair pay for equal work but also secure opportunities in industries and roles that offer long-term economic mobility.
References:
-
Frankfurt School of Finance & Management – Research by Professor Halil Sabanci
-
Nature (2025), original study publication