a computer chip with the letter a on top of it

Can Human Resources (HR) work be absorbed by Artificial Intelligence (AI) – and what are the dangers of such an approach for UK Plc?

The 2020s has provided headline writers with numerous opportunities to write about the rise of the robots and the impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the world of work.

This drip-feed of news stories has recently turned into a raging torrent of text as new – and largely unproven – AI tools pop up alongside everyday operating systems, phone apps, and business websites.  A few such AI tools are relatively useful and robust.  Many (most?) others are yet to prove their worth and remain inconsistent, “glitchy”, or even downright misleading.

Yet, whether we like it or not, AI is clearly here to stay.

Where will business use AI?

So how will British business get the most value from AI?

The answer will be to replace routine and repetitive work with automation where practical and possible.  Yet the employer’s challenge is how to identify and replace those everyday tasks without disadvantaging the customer or reducing productivity in the short term.

It follows that many businesses will look to back-office functions as the first target for automation.  This simple commercial reality may mean that Human Resources teams are amongst the first in the firing line as AI is adopted in the workplace.

AI in HR

This is already happening in some larger US companies.

In May Forbes magazine reported that around 94% of “routine HR tasks” are now handled by AI at computer giant IBM.  And there is already widespread use of AI to streamline recruitment processes across most large private sector employers and within the recruitment industry in particular.

And those same trends are already being echoed over here in the UK.  So, is this the end of Human Resources as we know it?

Glass half full?

Perhaps not.

Firstly, it is right and proper that businesses always look to technology to replace those routine and repetitive tasks that absorb so many human working hours for little or no return.  This has happened repeatedly since the start of the industrial revolution and there is no reason to think it will stop now.

Yet that doesn’t mean that HR will become entirely automated in the years to come.

Historical precedent

Indeed, history suggests something far more positive.

For instance, the UK unemployment rate in the early 1970s was around 4%.  From 1970 onwards the nation and businesses experienced and absorbed vast amounts of technological change yet the unemployment rate today remains not much different at 4.8% even though the national population is around 25% larger than it was in 1970.

When I entered the workforce in the 1980s most large offices included a staffed post-room, a paid-for tea lady with tea trolley, data input teams, and typing pools.  All of these jobs have long since disappeared.  Yet those roles have been seamlessly replaced with entirely new jobs that no one had thought about back then.  And this is not unusual.  It is estimated that a staggering 60% of today’s jobs did not exist in 1940.

Simply put, technology replaces some jobs but is also critical to creating new ones.

People prefer people

And then there is the simple reality that people prefer dealing with people.

When faced with a choice between an automated tool or human interaction many will prefer the latter.  And if you doubt me think of the challenges of using a vending machine, automatic car wash, or supermarket self-checkout compared to the human-staffed alternative.

So, whilst technology can replace many tasks, it often fails to do so.

Putting the Human in Human Resources

Which takes us back to the challenges of AI in HR.

Artificial Intelligence will (and already is) streamline many HR processes, particularly at the very largest employers such as IBM.  That said, it is likely that IBM and others will soon find that total reliance on technology in such a delicate area as Human Resources has the potential to damage workforce relations and lead to hiring and firing decisions that ultimately mute the creativity and future productivity of the wider organisation.  Once those lessons have been learned it is likely that a quiet re-employment and future expansion of HR will take place.

It should also be remembered that for many, perhaps most, SME’s the HR job functions are far more diverse and multi-purpose that at those very large employers.  It follows that the automation of such roles is more difficult and less easy to justify commercially too.

The bottom line is that humans remain central to human resources.  As long as we have employees then we will still need actual people to manage them.  And AI will help HR do just that.

Steve Herbert is Brand Ambassador for Occupational Health Assessment Limited and a veteran, award-winning, speaker and commentator on HR and Employee Benefit issues.