Zeeshan Anwar, Head of Compliance at Dolan Contractor Group considers what the future holds for IR35
IR35, or off-payroll working rules, are a set of tax laws that apply to contract workers who operate as a limited company. IR35 aims to differentiate between employees and contractors. However, it also weeds out any contractors posing as full-time employees for tax evasion purposes.
2022 was an eventful year for IR35 as rules were set to be repealed and then reverted. It’ll be known as a frustrating period of u-turns for many off-payroll contractors. Here we break down what happened in 2022 and what 2023 is set to look like for IR35 rules.
2022 recap
Mid-2022 began positively for the contracting community, with Liz Truss taking over as Prime Minister from Boris Johnson and promising to review IR35 rules. Kwasi Kwarteng unveiled the September mini-budget in April 2023, which set out plans to scrap the IR35 and any off-payroll working rules. The contracting community warmly welcomed this proposal and looked forward to the changes.
After the mini-budget was revealed, the proposed tax cuts saw the markets crash and the pound plummet. As a result, Jeremy Hunt took over from Kwasi Kwarteng and made plenty of u-turns, including the plan to repeal the IR35. So, can we expect any changes to the IR35 in 2023? After the u-turn, it’s unlikely, but with so many plans being reverted, we might see some changes take place this year.
Will IR35 change from April 2023?
Since the off-payroll working rules still stand, with no plans to repeal, no changes to the IR35 are anticipated. This means that contract workers who fall inside IR35 are still required to pay income tax and National Insurance. Contractors who fall outside IR35 remain responsible for determining their own tax. It’s up to the business to conclude whether or not their contracted employees fall inside or outside IR35. As a result, contractors who are outside IR35 will continue to face problems, including companies taking a risk-averse approach and not working with those outside IR35 in case they’re accused of contractors being ‘disguised employees’.
The government is set to make approximately £2bn per year by 2026-27 through the off-payroll working rules. Chancellor Hunt revealed in his statement that HMRC will receive a further £79 million to maintain tax compliance. HMRC could ramp up its enquiries into the IR35 compliance of many businesses, putting contractors outside the IR35 at a disadvantage.
The future of IR35
Whilst it’s frustrating for contractors and businesses alike that the IR35 and off-payroll working rules are here to stay, there have been some positive outcomes from the u-turns. It’s shone a new light on the IR35 and brought it to the attention of more people. As a result, businesses are being prompted to revisit their stance on IR35 workers, becoming more open to working with freelancers and contractors.
However, since Rishi Sunak has taken over the Prime Minister position, it’s unlikely that there’ll be further reforms to the IR35 in the near future.