The UK government’s Draft Finance Bill 2025-26, published this week, has reaffirmed HMRC’s intention to crack down on tax avoidance in the labour supply chain—particularly through the use of non-compliant umbrella companies. Among the measures announced is the introduction of joint and several liability for PAYE tax debts, placing the onus on recruitment firms to take greater responsibility for their umbrella company partners.

The new rules, scheduled to take effect from April 2026, aim to deter fraud and tax non-compliance by holding recruitment agencies financially accountable if any part of their umbrella supply chain fails to meet PAYE obligations.

While the broad direction of the legislation had been anticipated, the detail has raised significant concerns within the recruitment industry. Tania Bowers, Global Public Policy Director at the Association of Professional Staffing Companies (APSCo), offered a measured but critical response:

“The details published in yesterday’s Finance Bill were generally as expected. HMRC has clearly set its sights on preventing tax non-compliance, and fraud via umbrella companies are at the centre of its focus. HMRC has published draft legislation that will be introduced in April 2026 which puts the onus on recruitment firms through joint and several liability for PAYE taxes.

For recruitment firms, now is the time to prepare for the changes before they come into effect. During the consultation period, a few APSCo members expressed significant concerns around the legal implications, but there was a recognition that the legislation would create additional administrative burdens for recruiters that engage umbrella companies.

In particular, there are concerns as to the level of transparency that will be needed to protect recruitment firms. The guidance soon to be published by HMRC must outline not only its own approach, but also clear information to help staffing companies implement best practice strategies. The details published so far don’t provide recruiters with the additional tools to manage the new requirements; they simply put the responsibility on staffing firms to know the details of their umbrella supply chain, or face financial penalties.

There are some measures that will help recruiters and umbrella companies, including the specification around the transition phases for directors and the prevention of ‘Phoenixism’. However, more is needed. As APSCo has previously highlighted, licensing of the umbrella market and statutory codes of practice are needed to prevent fraud and equip those that are being tasked with tackling the issue with the appropriate resources to do so.

The digitalisation of services that has been touted as a means of helping small businesses interact with HMRC is welcome news, though the implementation of this will be no easy task. This needs to be made readily available as soon as possible in order to help staffing firms prepare ahead of the changes to legislation.

APSCo will continue to leverage its close relationship with HMRC to guide and inform members on the changes during the preparation period ahead of the April implementation.”

The government’s latest legislative push follows years of scrutiny into the umbrella company sector, which has faced repeated allegations of disguised remuneration schemes, tax evasion, and poor employment practices. By shifting liability up the supply chain, the government is seeking to increase accountability and reduce opportunities for abuse.

However, critics argue that the lack of statutory regulation of umbrella companies continues to leave legitimate staffing firms exposed, forced to act as de facto regulators without the necessary legal framework or tools.

Employer News will continue to follow developments on the Finance Bill and publish further guidance for recruiters and employers as HMRC releases detailed implementation plans in the coming months.

—

About APSCo

The Association of Professional Staffing Companies (APSCo) is the trade association for the professional recruitment market. APSCo Global comprises APSCo South East Asia, APSCo Australia, APSCo Deutschland and APSCo United Kingdom as well as APSCo OutSource, the trade body for the RPO and MSP sectors.

Find out more: www.apscouk.org

 

Image credit: Freepik