A recent employment tribunal has dismissed claims of race discrimination brought by a couple who were sacked from a Waitrose branch in Manchester after taking a holiday and extending it without permission. The couple had argued that they were dismissed due to their “tanned skin”, suggesting racial discrimination as the basis for their termination.
However, the tribunal found no evidence to support their claims, concluding instead that the dismissal was based on unauthorised absence, which constituted gross misconduct under Waitrose’s internal policies.
Kate Palmer, Employment Services Director at Peninsula, said the case serves as a clear reminder for HR professionals and employers to handle unauthorised absence with care:
“Unauthorised absence can occur for a variety of reasons. It’s important for employers not to have a knee-jerk approach but to deal with it carefully, ensuring they carry out as much investigation into the cause and circumstances as they can before taking any action, and if they have a policy, ensure that they follow it.
“Whilst the claims for discrimination on a number of grounds were struck out in this case, it does highlight the potential risks involved when dealing with unauthorised absence. If there is an underlying reason that might be linked to a protected characteristic, it is important for employers to explore this further and satisfy themselves the reason for the dismissal is not directly or indirectly because of this.
“In this instance, the judge agreed that after an investigation, and in line with the respondent’s handbook listing unauthorised absence as gross misconduct, the decision was made to dismiss the individuals because of their unauthorised absence, and not because of their protected characteristics.”
The ruling reinforces the importance of adhering to disciplinary procedures and ensuring a fair and thorough investigation when handling absences or allegations linked to potential protected characteristics.
For HR teams, the case underlines the need to ensure clear communication around absence policies, consistent documentation, and early engagement with employees to understand the reasons behind unexpected absences—particularly when there could be implications related to equality or diversity legislation.