Our Popular Blogger Steve Herbert considers whether improved employee engagement can lead to greater AI adoption, usage, and improved productivity.
Over the years I have written and spoken often on the subject of employee engagement. For those not familiar with this topic I would refer you to this definition from Gallup’s worldwide annual engagement survey:
“Employee engagement is the involvement and enthusiasm of employees in both their work and workplace. Highly engaged teams outperform the rest in business outcomes critical to the success of your organisation.”
Or, put more simply, engaged employees are likely to work that little bit harder, and therefore make your organisation more productive and profitable. It follows that it is in the employer’s interest to retain and improve engagement levels.
The United Kingdom
Yet the annual Gallup survey has consistently shown the UK as underperforming the world and competitor economies on employee engagement levels. This would be a problem at any time and in any economic cycle, yet is more concerning still given the global uncertainty and economic fragility of the UK at present.
How bad?
So how bad are things for the UK?
Globally the average level of employee engagement suggests that 20% off workers are fully engaged during their working day. Whereas the same data suggests that the UK is only half as engaged, with just 10% of employees feeling connected to their work.
Yet the world is a big place, and some of those economies and workforces may well represent a very different environment to those of the average UK business and worker. So how does the UK match up to our closest competitors and/or trading partners?
UK v Europe
The latest data suggests that engagement levels across Europe are less than exceptional. The average engagement level of European workers dropped by 1% in 2025 but still stands 2% higher than the UK at 12%.
There is of course a lot going on across the continent at present, with vastly differing economies, war on the Eastern flank, a pending energy and inflation crisis, political unease across many of the older democracies, and the shock waves from Trump’s tariffs wars still being felt across the EU region.
UK v G7
So, are there other comparators available to assess the true standing of UK employee engagement?
One solution might be to compare UK engagement levels with that rather nebulous grouping of major economic powers known as the G7. The G7 consists of (in alphabetical order) Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States of America. I have collated the engagement details of this grouping below:
Canada 21%
France: 8%
Germany: 11%
Italy: 11%
Japan: 8%
UK: 10%
USA: 32%
On this measure the United Kingdom is certainly off the pace with employee engagement, but not out of step with our largest European competitors and trading partners.
UK v The English-speaking world
Yet it won’t have escaped the reader’s notice that engagement in Britain is a long way behind our old allies in North America.
Not only that, but if we compare average engagement in the UK against those economies that are also largely English speaking then it is increasingly clear we have a problem:
Australia: 21%
Canada: 21%
New Zealand: 23%
United Kingdom: 10%
United States: 32%
This really highlights the problem. The UK is only half as engaged as most of these historic trading partners and less than a third as engaged as the economic powerhouse of the United States. And this despite a shared heritage and many similarities between the societies of the nations listed.
It is clear that the UK really needs to address employee engagement if we are to trade on equal terms with many of the developed economies in the world.
Will AI help?
But perhaps AI will improve productivity and remove the need for HR teams to address the rather daunting challenge of somehow improving employee engagement?
For the moment at least this seems rather unlikely. The Gallup report suggests that – despite a $40 billion investment in AI – almost 9 in 10 (89%) of global executives see no positive impact on productivity numbers. Not only that, but just 12% of employees in AI implemented organisations agree that AI has transformed how work gets done.
Why would this be? OpenAI suggested in their 2025 report;
“The primary constraints for organisations are no longer (AI) model performance or tooling, but rather organisational readiness and implementation.”
It seems likely that there is a lack of trust and engagement from workers to implement the AI solutions that might, or might not, ultimately prove beneficial to their businesses.
And that trust is hardly likely to blossom all the time workers have little emotional attachment to their work, and even less so if they feel actively threatened by the new technology.
So, before employers can go forward towards a more AI influenced world, they may need to take a step back to ensure that their existing workforce is fully engaged and motivated to take the next step in the technological journey.

Steve Herbert is Brand Ambassador for Occupational Health Assessment Limited and a veteran, award-winning, speaker and commentator on HR and Employee Benefit issues.