Employees who share similar motivations for achievement with their managers are significantly more likely to speak up and share their ideas, concerns, or feedback, according to new research by Durham University Business School.
The research also indicates that well-aligned employees and managers tend to feel a stronger connection to their organization and its identity.
These insights come from a study conducted by Dr. Janey Zheng, Professor of Leadership at Durham University Business School, along with Michele Williams from the University of Iowa, and Christina Wang and Jian Liang from Tongji University.
The researchers aimed to explore how alignment between employees’ and managers’ achievement goals and working standards influences employees’ likelihood to speak up to management with ideas, feedback, or concerns.
To investigate this, the researchers conducted two separate studies involving a collective sample of over 800 employee-supervisor pairs in Chinese firms. Participants were asked about their personal goals in their roles and their likelihood of voicing ideas, concerns, and feedback to their supervisors.
By matching employees’ answers with their leaders’, the researchers found that employees with similar goals and working standards to their supervisors were much more likely to speak up.
Interestingly, the research revealed that high motivation for achievement was not necessary for employees to speak up. Employees would share their thoughts even if they did not aim to be the best at work, as long as their supervisor shared the same perspective. However, if there was a mismatch in motivation levels—where one had high motivation and the other did not—employees were less likely to speak up.
“Employees feeling as though they have a voice is highly important to an organization,” says Dr. Zheng. “It brings new perspectives, ideas, and insights to the team, improving the organization. Additionally, employees who feel safe sharing feedback are more likely to be happy in their roles. Therefore, aligning the motivations of managers and workers should be a key goal for any organization.”
The researchers suggest that alignment can only occur if employees are aware of their manager’s goals. Organizations should pair supervisors with employees who share similar goals to ensure the whole team has a collective voice.
Another approach could involve managers sharing their vision with employees from the outset. If this is not feasible, organizations should consider hosting team-building programs, motivational speakers, and other activities to align the team’s goals.
Employees feeling empowered to voice their opinions is crucial for top managers because it generates innovative solutions to complex issues and enhances organizational effectiveness. Therefore, organizations should emphasize the importance of aligning managers’ and employees’ goals for the benefit of the entire organization.