Every summer, the same debate emerges in workplaces across the UK. School holidays arrive, annual leave requests increase, childcare challenges become more visible, and some employers begin questioning whether flexible working is really working. The school holidays arrive at roughly the same time every year so Anthony Sutton Managing Director of Cream HR asks why do these same issues crop up each year?

 

He believes that in reality flexible working isn’t the issue.  The problem is that the arrival of  school holidays expose weaknesses that already exist in the business such as poor planning, lack of trust and unclear expectations.

 

According to a study by the International Workplace Group (IWG), 61 percent of parents say that school holidays are a source of significant stress and while childcare isn’t a manager’s responsibility, it is important to be understanding.

 

This is a time when flexible working can really help but it only truly works when managers trust the people they have employed and acknowledge that most people are not looking to avoid work, they are just looking for ways  to make sure they have a good work-life balance.  The school holidays are a prime example of this.  They arrive every year and yet time and time again employers seem surprised by the increase in holiday requests and are scrambling to make sure workloads are fulfilled instead of making sure that they have a flexible working policy that is effective at this time of year.

 

Flexibility and accountability should go hand in hand.  Here are some things business leaders can do to ensure that flexible working works for everybody

 

Plan for predictable pressure points

  • School holidays, Christmas and other peak leave periods happen every year.
  • Encourage employees to submit leave requests early.
  • Create resource plans well in advance to avoid last-minute staffing issues.

Cross-train employees

  • Avoid creating single points of failure within teams.
  • Ensure key tasks and knowledge are shared across multiple employees.
  • Build resilience so that cover can be provided when needed.

Focus on outputs, not presenteeism

  • Measure performance by results rather than time spent online or at a desk.
  • Set clear objectives and expectations.
  • Give employees the autonomy to decide how they achieve agreed outcomes.

Be transparent about decisions

  • Explain how flexible working requests are assessed.
  • Communicate openly about business needs and team capacity.
  • Consistency helps reduce perceptions of favouritism.

Offer flexibility fairly

  • Flexibility should not be seen as a benefit reserved for parents.
  • Employees may need flexibility for caring responsibilities, health appointments, study commitments or personal wellbeing.
  • Consider how flexibility can support the whole workforce.
  • Consider reviewing the home-working policy and share ways of working that can help employees avoid distractions.

Train managers properly

  • Managing flexible teams requires different skills.
  • Equip managers to have conversations about workloads, accountability and performance.
  • Build trust through regular communication rather than constant monitoring.

One of the biggest mistakes organisations make during the school holidays is assuming that flexibility for one employee automatically creates problems for everyone else. Resentment rarely comes from flexibility, it often stems from poor communication and the perception that some employees are being treated differently.

It shouldn’t be assumed that everybody values flexibility in the same way. While some may need to adjust their hours around childcare, others may want flexibility to pursue training, care for elderly relatives, attend medical appointments or simply maintain their wellbeing. Creating a culture where flexibility is available to everyone, where operationally possible, helps prevent divisions forming within teams.

It is also important to have honest conversations about workload and cover arrangements. Employees are often far more willing to support colleagues when they understand the reasons behind decisions and know that flexibility is being managed fairly. Transparency helps build trust not only between managers and employees, but also between team members themselves.

This is an area where technology can also play a valuable role. Shared calendars, project management tools and clear communication channels make it easier for teams to coordinate workloads, identify possible gaps and ensure responsibilities are covered during periods of leave. When businesses rely on informal arrangements or last-minute requests, problems are more likely to arise.

The organisations that navigate peak holiday periods the best are not always those with the most generous policies, but the ones that have created a culture of trust, planned ahead and established clear expectations for everyone.

Anthony says: “Flexible working doesn’t fail because employees can’t be trusted. It fails when organisations try to offer flexibility without building the trust, planning and management structures needed to support it. School holidays don’t create workforce problems, they simply expose them.”

Flexible working does not fail because employees can’t be trusted. It fails when businesses try to implement it without the planning, communication and trust needed to ensure it is successful.

When organisations treat employees like adults, with clear expectations and a focus on results, flexibility becomes a tool for improving engagement, retention and productivity, not a source of conflict.