Payroll management is a critical but resource-intensive task at most organizations. Smaller organizations might outsource payroll management to external service providers, a choice that makes sense when your HR team is smaller. However, these companies often run into issues with payroll workflows as they scale up and headcounts grow.

Working with an outsourced payroll bureau can cause efficiency bottlenecks for companies with larger teams. Companies in these situations may be better off moving payroll processing in-house. Here are three glaring signs that indicate it’s time to make the change and “insource” your company’s payroll management.

Payroll requires as much management as core business tasks

Project management efficiency is pivotal at any company. However, if working with an external payroll service means that you’re constantly working around a third-party company’s deadlines, contending with cut-off dates for submitting details, and sweating task assignments, chances are your service vendor is not flexible enough to accommodate your needs.

Outsourced payroll providers service several clients at once, leading them to impose arbitrary submission deadlines for each company. These deadlines are usually out of sync with a company’s payroll workflows and regulatory deadlines, and they compromise your ability to be agile with payroll close dates, custom payroll cycles, or swift error correction.

As a result, companies that use these vendors must ensure all data is accurate and ready in advance. This inflexibility becomes a no-go for growing organizations, since adding employees at a fast clip and need to make adjustments on the fly.

By using Pento’s automated UK payroll platform, it’s far easier for HR teams to overcome these challenges. The system leads you through the workflow process, gathers employee data from integrated third-party information systems, flags any potential issues, and allows you to adjust on the fly – right up until you close payroll.

Your company relies on complex financial projections to grow

Small companies generally operate based on basic financial projections like budgets versus actuals and expected cash flow over the next few months. However, growing companies have a completely different set of requirements, and payroll data plays a central role in planning models.

For instance, growing companies usually project where their revenues will land by the end of the year. These companies may have boards and investors scrutinizing every financial disclosure and cannot afford to present inaccurate data. In such a scenario, using payroll data pulled from a PDF report that an outsourced service provider sent you a few weeks ago is unlikely to work well.

It’s hard to project revenues accurately without accounting for employee hiring plans and the costs that come with them. Outdated, PDF-based payroll data makes it hard to create growth projection ranges and customized hiring plans. In these situations, it’s too challenging to model different scenarios that reveal the most cost-effective way to grow.

If you’re using a strategic finance platform like Drivetrain, or any other financial planning and analysis solution, you need real-time payroll data, which is only actionable if you’re using an in-house system. This gives you the flexibility to create different growth models, calculate sales capacity needs, and create customized hiring plans from those inputs.

Growth involves much more than simply “selling more units” of your product or service. It is the result of careful financial planning that models different inputs and regularly crunches numbers to find the best growth path. Outsourced payroll service providers cannot offer you the critical input you need regularly enough to plan growth.

You use complex employee compensation formulas

Growing companies have the resources to hire top-tier talent. However, top-tier talent isn’t swayed by vanilla compensation packages. They demand equity, custom benefits, and individual perks. In this sense, salaries are just the starting point.

An outsourced payroll service provider might be able to accommodate custom benefits, but they will struggle to execute payroll workflows on time if the majority of your employees have sophisticated compensation formulas that need to take several performance metrics into account.

Payroll that accommodates these elements can also involve reporting and compliance complexity. Even if your outsourced service provider is willing to take on the additional work, you might find that you’re spending so much time breaking everything down for them that it would be more efficient to handle it yourself.

Integrating your payroll platform with a solution like Vantage Circle helps you model custom compensation plans, view costs, and their impact on your growth projections. With everything connected seamlessly like this, you will instantly know how much you can afford to pay new prospective employees and negotiate custom plans with them accordingly.

For instance, you could negotiate lower health benefits but offer other perks like a housing allowance, which can be helpful in terms of tax implications. Alternatively, you can offer benefits to employees in remote international locations tailored to their needs. An employee in Southeast Asia will likely have different demands from one based in North America.

An in-house payroll ecosystem will give you all the data you need instantly without having to turn to an outside source to run the most basic reports.

In-housing payroll makes sense for growing companies

Outsourced payroll is cost-effective and reduces workloads for small companies. However, as businesses grow, they start to encounter different, more complex needs that a third-party service isn’t necessarily optimized to address. Growing companies need more agility and flexibility, and given payroll’s position as a critical expense, bringing payroll workflows in-house often makes the most sense.