Arlington, US, oct. 22 2023: Donald Trump 2024 presidential campaign flag waving with american flag waving together. 2024 US presidential election. Illustrative editorial 3d illustration render

Our regular columnist, Steve Herbert, considers the impact of Trump 2.0 on workplaces worldwide

The Chinese Year of the Snake begins this week.  I know next to nothing about the Chinese Zodiac, but I do know that in Western culture the snake is seen as both a dangerous and unpredictable being.  That position is echoed in another new arrival (in the West rather than the East) of President Donald Trump 2.0.

The returning President has already lost little time in shaking the snow-globe of domestic and global issues, and at the time of writing it is almost impossible to know which of his many executive orders presents the most change and/or potential risks.  Yet there is one issue that will almost certainly have some implications for the UK workplace, and that is the so-called US “War on Woke”.

The retreat from DEI

Even before Trump won the Presidential election there were a number of major US employers announcing significant reductions – or even complete reversals – of their (often flagship) Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies (known as EDI here in the UK).

That trickle of DEI retreats has become a torrent since Trump won control of all the levers of USA power in November, and the surge is only likely to intensify following the new President’s executive orders that the US government would only recognise two genders, and his instruction that government departments should cease all DEI initiatives also.

Impact on the UK workplace

Yet what has any of this got to do with the UK?

The truth is that so many of the major employers already rowing-back on some or all of their DEI commitments are also major employers here in the UK.  This Forbes magazine article from early January lists many organisations that are household names over here, including Ford, Meta, McDonalds, Boeing, and Amazon.

Now I recognise that the US is both another state and cited thousands of miles away on another continent, and also that employment rights and laws are markedly different between the two countries.  Yet I find it inconceivable that the mega-organisations listed above will be able to retain corporate culture positions on DEI/EDI that are polar opposites on either side of the Atlantic without looking ridiculous and also encouraging workforce unrest.  It therefore follows that we should expect to see some UK employers quietly retreating from their EDI commitments in the months immediately ahead.

What about “Making Work Pay”?

Another implication is that the new US position appears to be a bad fit with the UK government’s flagship improvements (and manifesto commitments) to “Making Work Pay” here in Britain.  The raft of measures promised by the Labour party were set to provide a “once in a generation” improvement to UK worker rights, yet at least some components of that approach were centred on fairness and inclusion, particularly the promises linked to enhanced pay-gap reporting.  Will these promises survive contact with the anti-woke and big business reality lobby now likely emboldened over here by the return of Trump?

What is clear is that events “over there” have the potential to make a real difference to the jobs of millions of workers and HR professionals “over here”.

Employer views

I spoke on this issue at the Occupational Health Assessment Ltd HR Employment Webinar just 24 hours after Donald Trump’s second inauguration, and it appears that many employers agree with my assertions above.   Almost 7 in 10 employers (69%) considered at least some curtailment to UK EDI policies is now likely, whereas only 15% did not expect US actions to lead to change in the UK workplace.

The personal views of the (largely HR) attendance were rather interesting too.  The audience was split as to whether the roll-back of EDI would be a good or bad thing.  Admittedly more than half (53%) thought current EDI policies were about right or needed to be further strengthened, yet more than a third of respondents (37%) thought that at least some aspects of EDI required curtailment or change.

It will take a little time for the picture to settle down, but I would suggest that Trump 2.0 may have a much more marked impact on the UK workplace than anyone would have predicted just a few months ago.

Steve Herbert is Brand Ambassador for Occupational Health Assessment Ltd and a veteran, award-winning, speaker and commentator on HR and Employee Benefit issues.

—

Image credit: Deposit Photos