As the cost of living crisis in the UK continues to bite, the Government is seeking to pass new legislation in order to crackdown on the mass strike action being undertaken by workers whose pay has failed to keep pace with inflation.
The government is determined to see its new anti-strike bill come into practice. However, more recently trade union leaders as well as train operators have criticised the proposed laws raising a cause for concern; stating they would be dangerous for employees and could worsen industrial relations. We spoke to Samantha Greer, Senior Consultant at Setfords Solicitors, to see how the proposed new laws will impact have on unions and employees.
Samantha said:
Strike actions are cyclical.
If we were to look back to history the last major strike action with significant disruption was in September 1979 when around £12,000,000 working days were lost due to labour disputes. In total, an estimated 2.472 million working days were lost between June and December 2022. Of these, 79% came from workers in transport, storage, information and communication.
There is an argument that whilst these recent figures don’t look particularly attractive for the United Kingdom to the rest of the World, historical events such as these are fairly cyclical and transitory. Let’s not forget, during the major strikes in 1979, Britain’s inflation rate was 20.1%. Today (44 years on) we are seeing signs of inflation in Europe and the US at half and now seeing signs of it reducing.
The Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 (TULRCA 1992) is the relevant legislation. If a trade union authorises a strike that impacts an employment contract, it will be liable in tort unless it has complied with a number of requirements set out in TULRCA. New section 234B would allow the Secretary of State to make “minimum service regulations”, setting minimum service levels for strikes in those “Relevant Services”. “Relevant Services” are to be defined in future regulations but must be limited to certain sectors.
Interestingly Border Security was not originally deemed a relevant service as it states “The government hopes to not have to use these powers for other sectors included in the Bill, such as education, other transport services, border security, other health services and nuclear decommissioning.”
If passed, how will it work?
It depends on whether or not you fall into the category of “relevant services”. If this applies, then the Union will give the employer e.g Network Rail or its successor, a strike notice under section 234A and in return, the employer has 7 days before the day of strike action to issue a “work notice” stating which employees are required to work and what work they are required to do. The Employer will not request more workers than is “reasonably necessary” (asking for trouble here!)
This does however raise a few things that change things significantly:
“Loss of union immunity.”
If the Union fails to take reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the “work notice” by any union members identified in it, this loss of immunity could potentially lead to more applications for an injunction by the employer. The employer would also be entitled to sue the union for damages caused by any failure to take reasonable steps (but disregarding any loss that would have been caused by the strike if the union had complied).
Employees would lose entitlements to unfair dismissal claims for noncompliance with a work notice.
An employee can still take part in a strike if a work notice is issued in his/her name and will not be in breach of the work notice (as this is a notice to the Union, not the employee). However. if an employee is identified in a work notice (whether they are a union member or not) and then goes on strike, they will lose unfair dismissal protection if they are in breach of the work notice regardless of the immense pressures that we have seen on picket lines against non-striking employees.
Will it work?
Fundamentally it will require both sides to be collaborative. At this moment in time, each side is hardened in its position. The legislation requires the employer to “consult” with the Unions on the number of employees subject to the Work Notice before the Work notice is issued. If there are no measures to dispute the Work Notice then why is there a duty to consult with the Unions?
Affecting the individual’s right to an unfair dismissal claim, is perhaps, a step too far.