Across U.K boardrooms, the debate over how to boost productivity and performance has become increasingly urgent. Some organisations are rolling back hybrid arrangements in favour of five days in the office, while others are turning to employee-monitoring software or stricter performance targets, all in pursuit of higher output. Yet these approaches often come at the expense of employee wellbeing, driven by a belief that wellbeing and performance are mutually exclusive. In reality, leaders don’t need to choose between the two. A healthy performance culture is entirely achievable when high expectations are matched with high levels of support. Here’s how to achieve it.

The four culture variants

To start with, it’s important to understand the different types of workplace culture, and why some can deliver great work output while maintaining high levels of employee wellbeing.

Uninvolved cultures have low expectations of their employees and provide a low level of support. Perhaps unsurprisingly, these are the least healthy and least productive.

Permissive cultures have low expectations with high support. While an improvement on uninvolved cultures, the lack of employee challenges compromise productivity and can eventually impact engagement.

High expectations but low support are found in authoritarian cultures. These are epitomised by leaders demanding a lot from employees but providing few resources to help them achieve their goals. These cultures don’t encourage employees to feedback or contribute their opinions, compromising both employee wellbeing and productivity.

Finally, authoritative cultures are the most productive and healthiest as they have high expectations while providing high levels of support. Employees can more easily realise their goals without sacrificing their wellbeing.

The key is for leaders to cultivate an authoritative culture for the greatest chance of great work and better outcomes for all. Such a culture provides a range of support including growth and development opportunities, a voice in decisions, transparent communication, and sufficient resources for employees to do their jobs. And when employees feel well supported, they are 47% less likely to experience depression, 44% less likely to suffer with anxiety and the chances of burnout are decreased by 88%. Plus people in authoritative cultures have the longest expected retention, suggesting that high support and expectations produce the highest level of loyalty.

Steps to an authoritative culture

To nurture a culture in which employees are both challenged to deliver great work while being treated well in the process, requires a number of key elements to come together.

The first is that leaders and managers must set clear, inspirational but achievable goals. These goals need to be comprehensively communicated so employees understand what they need to achieve, and how the goals fit into the company’s overall purpose. At the same time, the communications channels must always stay open so employees are able to feedback and ask questions. Managers must ensure there are regular interactions with employees, including one-to-ones and team meetings.

Ongoing development opportunities must be provided, including mentorship and growth projects, so employees are stretched without feeling overwhelmed. These must take place hand-in-hand with high levels of emotional and practical support to ensure challenges are met with confidence and resilience. Leaders need to provide everyone with the right tools, actively encourage mental health discussions, show empathy, and signpost employees to resources for improving mental health and addressing burnout.

Finally, effective employee recognition should be a natural and consistent part of workplace culture – one that validates, encourages, and celebrates people’s contributions. Recognition needs to be frequent and reflect the full spectrum of employee impact, whether it’s achieving individual or team goals, going above and beyond, or contributing to key company milestones. Making recognition specific and personal by highlighting what the individual uniquely brought to the moment, ensures it remains meaningful, memorable, and genuinely supportive. Recognition becomes even more powerful when employees’ accomplishments are clearly linked to the organisation’s purpose and goals, reinforcing how their work advances the company while demonstrating that they’re meeting or exceeding expectations.

Exceling without burnout

Performance and wellbeing thrive together when leaders cultivate a culture that stretches people while supporting them every step of the way. By setting clear goals, investing in development, keeping communication channels open, and supporting and recognising every individual, organisations enable employees to excel without burnout. The result is a stronger and healthier workforce that fuels lasting performance.

Written by Robert Ordever, European MD of employee recognition specialist, O.C. Tanner