According to new research from GRiD, the industry body for the group risk sector, nearly eight in ten employers (77%) have directly funded employee support on a case-by-case basis when an employee was ill or injured.

Katharine Moxham, spokesperson for GRiD, said: “At first glance, directly funding support for an employee may seem like a good thing to do, but it can create a number of challenges for employers. Costs can escalate rapidly, and maintaining fairness and consistency across the workforce can become difficult.

“Taken together, these challenges highlight that a case-by-case approach is not the most effective route for most organisations. A more structured solution, backed by clear processes, can help ensure employees receive appropriate support, while employers retain control over costs and maintain fairness across their workforce.”

The funding challenge

One of the most significant risks is the lack of budgetary oversight and high costs.

GRID warns that while spend may initially appear manageable, support for serious conditions, such as cancer, can quickly escalate into the tens or even hundreds of thousands of pounds for just one individual member of staff. As these expenses are often unexpected, they can place significant pressure on an organisation, affecting budgets and ultimately impacting the bottom line. It could also lead to potential and unintended P11D implications for the employee.

The equality challenge

A separate concern is that once support has been provided to one employee, other employees may expect similar support, and not only can that can further drive up costs over time, it may also expose the employer to a legal challenge for discrimination.

The knowledge challenge

A further challenge is ensuring employees receive the support most likely to deliver the best outcomes as quickly as possible. Support and rehabilitation often require a range of interventions, frequently incorporating both mental and physical health, delivered when needed and in a coordinated way. When employees have access to timely, holistic support, they are more like to have better health outcomes, and less time off work.

Employee benefits, particularly group risk – employer-sponsored life assurance, income protection and critical illness cover – can play an important role in helping organisations manage these challenges. In addition to providing financial protection, support can also incorporate physical and mental health, such as access to oncologists, second medical opinions, physio and counselling. They also enable employers to manage their costs and treat employees consistently. And as the support is included at no extra cost to employers or staff, the case for group risk benefits is a compelling one.

Katharine Moxham said: “It is often surprising how many employers get caught out when trying to do the right thing. They step in to support employees during difficult circumstances, only to find the illness or injury requires a level of support far beyond what was anticipated. Employers should be recognised for their willingness to help staff at these crucial moments, but funding support on a case-by-case basis can create challenges for both the employee and the business.”